The reform of intergovernmental fiscal relations in developing and emerging market economies

Abstract

No AccessStand Alone Books1 Feb 2013The reform of intergovernmental fiscal relations in developing and emerging market economiesAuthors/Editors: Anwar ShahAnwar Shahhttps://doi.org/10.1596/0-8213-2836-0SectionsAboutPDF (0.6 MB) ToolsAdd to favoritesDownload CitationsTrack Citations ShareFacebookTwitterLinked In Abstract:An important dimension of public sector reform in developing and emerging market economies has been the loosening of central control over the private sector and lower level governments. The author's overview of the principles and best practices of fiscal federalism should help guide policy debates on restructuring intergovernmental fiscal arrangements. Strong emphasis on central planning impedes innovative responses to local issues by local governments and stymies private sector development. Decentralization should be the rule, the author argues, unless a strong case can be made for centralizing specific responsibilities. Local public services can be provided more efficiently if expenditures more closely match local needs and preferences. More closely linking benefits to costs also promotes accountability. Increased fiscal autonomy can also help mobilize more revenue from local sources, improving a country's fiscal position. And decentralized desicion-making encourages local participation in development. Constitutional responsibilities should be stated clearly and precisely. Tax and spending assignments should be determined simultaneously, so revenue means are matched as closely as possible to spending needs at each level of government. In most developing countries, subnational governments have limited access to their own tax bases and depend on higher level transfers. A grant's design should reflect the situation and objectives. The author gives examples. Although most countries give a high priority to limiting interregional fiscal disparities, no developing or transitional economy has adopted an explicit standard for equalization. Revenue sharing should be supplemented by an equilization program with a specified standard rather than by combining several factors into one formula. Local borrowing to meet capital expenditures is a major issue in most developing countries. In such cases, autonomous bodies can supervise and assist local borrowing for capital projects. The decentralization of responsibilities and the rationalization of intergovernmental transfers should be supported by strengthening local institutional capabilities. Monitoring, auditing, and inspections functions in most developing nations especially need to be strengthened. Transitional economies also need to give high priority to establishing or improving framework laws on property rights, corporate legal ownership and control, and bankruptcy, and financial accounting and control. FiguresreferencesRecommendeddetailsCited byRevenue Sharing from Natural Resources: Principles and Practices22 February 2023Managing transitions for sustainable economic development in post-COVID world: do fiscal and monetary support matter?Economic Research-Ekonomska Istraživanja, Vol.35, No.12 February 2022LOCAL FINANCIAL AUTONOMY AS A PREREQUISITE FOR IMPROVING THE PROVISION OF PUBLIC SERVICES AND GOODS: THE CASE OF THE REPUBLIC OF MOLDOVABaltic Journal of Economic Studies, Vol.8, No.530 December 2022A review of Ireland's Local Property TaxAdministration, Vol.70, No.424 December 2022Spatial interdependence and spillovers of fiscal grants in Benin: Static and dynamic diffusionsWorld Development, Vol.158Fiscal Decentralization and Fiscal Multiplier in ChinaThe B.E. Journal of Macroeconomics, Vol.22, No.218 November 2021Inequality of Intergovernmental Transfer of Value Added TaxesThe Journal of Planning and Budgeting, Vol.27, No.11 May 2022Decentralization Can Improve Equity, but Can It Be Sustained?Health Systems & Reform, Vol.8, No.16 June 2022Indirect Federal Subsidy and Tax Exportation through State and Local Tax Deduction: Understanding the Impact of the 2017 Tax Reform on State and Local GovernmentsPublius: The Journal of Federalism, Vol.52, No.13 August 2021Key Principles of Fiscal Decentralization17 November 2021Ethiopia: Ugly Mathematical Unit Cost Fiscal Equalization Formula; Beautiful FindingsInternational Journal of Business and Management Research, Vol.9, No.13 March 2021Rwanda: Lessons from Applied Intergovernmental Fiscal Equalization FormulaInternational Journal of Business and Management Research, Vol.8, No.430 December 2020Fiscal stability during the Great Recession: putting decentralization design to the testRegional Studies, Vol.54, No.724 July 2019Evaluating the Conditionality of External Development Assistance Programs3 November 2020Evaluation of Decentralization Programs3 November 2020Local governance in Switzerland: Adequate municipal autonomy cumintergovernmental cooperation?Cogent Social Sciences, Vol.6, No.113 May 2020EFFECTS OF FEDERAL CONSTITUTIONAL GRANTS IN BRAZILIAN MUNICIPALITIESReview of Urban & Regional Development Studies, Vol.637 October 2019Conclusion: Toward an Asymmetrical Decentralization Design28 November 2018Expenditure and Revenue Assignment: Principles6 September 2019Local Public Finance and Economics: Theory and the Practice—Introduction and Overview6 September 2019The Chinese developmental state: standard accounts and new characteristicsJournal of International Relations and Development, Vol.21, No.328 February 2017Yaklaşım, İlke ve Unsurları Çerçevesinde Mali Yerelleşmeyi AnlamakTESAM Akademi Dergisi27 April 2018Fiscal Equalisation in Polish Municipalities (Example of Lower Silesian Voivodship)2 July 2018EU Research and Technology Policy: Balancing Between the National and the EU Dimension18 November 2017Federal Governments Around the World: A Comparative PerspectiveSSRN Electronic JournalFiscal Decentralization and Delivery of Public Services: Evidence from Education Sector in PakistanStudies in Business and Economics, Vol.12, No.115 June 2017Oil windfalls and X-inefficiency: evidence from BrazilJournal of Economic Studies, Vol.43, No.5The theoretical and methodical aspects of creation of budget space of regionsEconomy of Industry, Vol.75, No.330 September 2016The relationship between IRA and local government expenditures: evidence from a cross-section of Philippine citiesPhilippine Political Science Journal, Vol.37, No.329 November 2016Intensity of Fiscal Illusion in Local Self-Government in Poland: Trends and ThreatsInternational Journal of Trade, Economics and Finance, Vol.7, No.31 June 2016Study on Fiscal Transfer Payment System Reform in China—Based on the Perspective of a New Road to UrbanizationModern Economy, Vol.06, No.08Has decentralisation affected child immunisation status in Indonesia?Global Health Action, Vol.7, No.125 August 2014Extending the "voting with the feet" proposition: the impact of local economic development actions on immigration across Mexican municipalitiesSpace and Polity, Vol.18, No.330 August 2014Intergovernmental Fiscal Arrangements and Provincial Consumption Risk Sharing in ChinaEmerging Markets Finance and Trade, Vol.50, No.327 September 2014Fiscal Federalism and Intergovernmental Financial RelationsWhy 'small is beautiful' in municipal disaster risk reduction: Evidence from the Yucatán peninsula, MexicoEnvironmental Hazards, Vol.11, No.2IntroductionHealth Development in the Decentralized Health System of the Philippines: Impact of Local Health Expenditures on HealthFiscal Decentralization in the Philippines after the 1991 Code: Intergovernmental Fiscal Relationships and the Roles of Fiscal TransfersIntergovernmental Fiscal Relationships in Vietnam after the 2002 State Budget Law: The Center-Province and the Province-District/Commune DimensionsThe Diversity of Fiscal Decentralization Below Provincial Level and Its Relation to Development in Vietnam: Do More Decentralized Provinces Improve Health and Economic Equity?Fiscal Federalism Amid Institutional Weakness: The Argentine Fiscal Pacts of the 1990sLatin American Policy, Vol.2, No.210 November 2011Does HIV Services Decentralization Protect against the Risk of Catastrophic Health Expenditures? Some Lessons from CameroonHealth Services Research, Vol.46, No.6pt226 September 2011SUBNATIONAL TAXATION IN DEVELOPING COUNTRIES: A REVIEW OF THE LITERATUREJournal of International Commerce, Economics and Policy, Vol.02, No.017 April 2012Fiscal Decentralization and Provincial-Level Fiscal Disparities in China: A Sino-U.S. Comparative PerspectivePublic Administration Review, Vol.69Fiscal Decentralization, Chinese Style: Good for Health Outcomes?World Development, Vol.37, No.12Assigning State Taxes in a Federal Country: The Case of AustraliaSSRN Electronic JournalResource Windfalls, Fiscal Effort and Public Spending: Evidence from Brazilian MunicipalitiesSSRN Electronic JournalFiscal Federalism in the European Union: How Far Are We?Citizen-centred Local Governance: Strategies to combat democratic deficitsDevelopment, Vol.50, No.15 March 2007Descentralization and Good Governance in ColombiaSSRN Electronic JournalFiscal decentralization and macroeconomic managementInternational Tax and Public Finance, Vol.13, No.4MADISON IN BAGHDAD?: Decentralization and Federalism in Comparative PoliticsAnnual Review of Political Science, Vol.9, No.1Legislative Institutions and Fiscal PolicySSRN Electronic JournalPrivate and Government Consumption in Transitional Economies: A Panel Data AnalysisSSRN Electronic JournalFiscal decentralization, revenue and expenditure assignments, and growth in ChinaJournal of Asian Economics, Vol.16, No.6Devolution and Regional Disparities in the Philippines: Is There a Connection?Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy, Vol.23, No.330 November 2016Federalism and the Market, Vol.1120 July 2009Comparative Decentralization Lessons from Pakistan, Indonesia, and the PhilippinesPublic Administration Review, Vol.65, No.2An evaluation of the property tax in TanzaniaProperty Management, Vol.23, No.1Strengthening Municipal Fiscal Autonomy Through Intergovernmental Transfers10 March 2015Iraq: Considerationson Intergovernmental Fiscal Relations for the Constituent AssemblyIMF Working Papers, Vol.05, No.69Closing the Gap: Fiscal Imbalances and Intergovernmental Transfers in Developed FederationsEnvironment and Planning C: Government and Policy, Vol.22, No.130 November 2016Fiscal Decentralization in the Czech and Slovak Republics: A Comparative Study of Moral HazardEnvironment and Planning C: Government and Policy, Vol.22, No.130 November 2016Adequacy of Korea?s Tax Assignment: A Fiscal Federalism ApproachInternational Review of Public Administration, Vol.9, No.2Fiscal Decentralization and Economic GrowthWorld Development, Vol.31, No.9Bailouts, Budget Constraints, and LeviathansComparative Political Studies, Vol.36, No.51 July 2016Can city governments in the South deliver for the poor?: A municipal finance perspectiveInternational Development Planning Review, Vol.25, No.1Moral Hazard in Property Tax Administration: A Comparative Analysis of the Czech and Slovak RepublicsComparative Economic Studies, Vol.45, No.126 March 2003Fiscal decentralisation in Africa: a framework for considering reformPublic Administration and Development, Vol.23, No.11 January 2003Sectoral decentralisation and intergovernmental arrangements in AfricaPublic Administration and Development, Vol.23, No.11 January 2003Decentralization and Local Government in Bolivia: An Overview from the Bottom UpSSRN Electronic JournalLocal fiscal equalisation based on fiscal capacity: the case of AustriaFiscal Studies, Vol.23, No.12 February 2005Fiscal Decentralization in Mexico: The Bailout ProblemSSRN Electronic JournalPopulation as a Determinant of Local Outcomes under Decentralization: Illustrations from Small Municipalities in Bolivia and MexicoWorld Development, Vol.29, No.8STRATEGIES FOR ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT UNDER DECENTRALIZATION: A TRANSFORMATION OF THE POLITICAL ECONOMYInternational Journal of Public Administration, Vol.24, No.10Federal politics and market reform in the developing worldStudies in Comparative International Development, Vol.36, No.2The Principles of Parallel Development of Fiscal Capacity between State and Municipalities as Useful Benchmarks for the Determination of the Inter-governmental Grants in GermanyEuropean Planning Studies, Vol.9, No.410 November 2009Agricultural taxation in developing countries: a survey of issues and policyAgricultural Economics, Vol.24, No.3Fiscal Decentralization and Economic GrowthSSRN Electronic JournalDoes Decentralization Increase Government Responsiveness to Local Needs? Evidence from BoliviaSSRN Electronic JournalFiscal Decentralization: A Political Theory with Latin American CasesWorld Politics, Vol.53, No.213 June 2011Différenciation régionale et fédéralisme budgétaire en RussieCritique internationale, Vol.11, No.2The Subnational Politics of Economic AdjustmentComparative Political Studies, Vol.33, No.430 June 2016The Politics of Decentralization in Latin AmericaLatin American Research Review, Vol.34, No.15 October 2022Fiscal decentralization in Indonesia: A comment on smoke and lewisWorld Development, Vol.26, No.12An Equalization Transfer System in JapanFiscal Decentralization and Government Size in Latin AmericaSSRN Electronic JournalDecentralizing agricultural extension: alternative strategiesInternational Journal of Lifelong Education, Vol.16, No.5Agricultural extension into the next decadeEuropean Journal of Agricultural Education and Extension, Vol.4, No.1Redemocratization and Decentralization in Brazil: The Strength of the Member StatesDevelopment and Change, Vol.27, No.3Fiscal externalities and the design of intergovernmental grantsInternational Tax and Public Finance, Vol.3, No.3Agricultural extension in transition worldwide: structural, financial and managerial strategies for improving agricultural extensionPublic Administration and Development, Vol.16, No.24 December 1998Introduction: Fiscal Aspects of Evolving FederationsInternational Tax and Public Finance, Vol.3, No.2DECENTRALIZATION: TOWARD A REVITALIZED STRATEGY FOR RURAL DEVELOPMENTAgrekon, Vol.34, No.4Expenditure-Based Equalization Transfers View Published: June 1994ISBN: 978-0-8213-2836-1 Copyright & Permissions Related RegionsEast Asia & PacificLatin America & CaribbeanSouth AsiaRelated CountriesBrazilIndiaIndonesiaMexicoRelated TopicsFinance and Financial Sector DevelopmentUrban Development KeywordsDECENTRALIZATIONINTERGOVERNMENTAL FISCAL RELATIONSPUBLIC SERVICESFISCAL ADMINISTRATIONTAX ADMINISTRATIONLOCAL GOVERNMENTSUBNATIONAL GOVERNMENTCAPITAL COSTSREVENUE SHARINGSTANDARDIZATIONPRIVATE SECTORPUBLIC SECTORFINANCIAL MANAGEMENTEQUALIZATIONEXPENDITURE ASSIGNMENTINTERGOVERNMENTAL FISCAL RELATIONSINTERGOVERNMENTAL TRANSFERSLOCAL GOVERNMENTSPUBLICPUBLIC SECTORREVENUE SHARINGTAXURBAN PUBLIC SERVICES PDF DownloadLoading ...