The “books” which make up the so‐called Deuteronomistic History — Joshua, Judges, Samuel, Kings — are acknowledged to be the result of divisions made in the History long after its creation. In fact, there are two canonical sequences of books that have historical and continuing importance: the Masoretic canon (as above), and the LXX/Christian canon of Joshua, Judges, Ruth, 1 and 2 Samuel, 1 and 2 Kings. But there is no reason why these “books” should be retained as reading units for the purpose of literary study of the text; for example, the units proposed by Martin Noth and Dennis McCarthy (approximately Joshua, Judges 1–1 Samuel 12, 1 Samuel 13–2 Samuel 7, etc) provide an alternative (and might just as well be calles “books"!). But the traditional books have come to be regarded as stable literary objects, a tendency solidified by genres like the commentary series. Some readers (Joel Rosenberg, Robert Polzin) even claim that the division into books follows the natural contours of the Deuteronomic text. It is here claimed that any division of the text is, in Marxist terms, an act of literary production in a contested ideological space, and that this applies not only to ancient canonical processes, but also to the choices that modern scholars make. The reading of what is now “1 Samuel”, especially of its opening chapters, is shown to be very different according to which of the above three “book” divisions (Noth‐McCarthy, Masoretic, LXX/Christian) is assumed. For example, Lyle Eslinger's claim that only the Elides, and not Israel at large, are blamed for the defeat in 1 Samuel 4, depends on a reading which begins at 1 Samuel 1. This simple example leads into discussion of how the reader's view of judgeship and kingship is shaped by the division into books. Finally, a much fuller example, how to read the character Hannah, links the discussion to a broad range of recent feminist work (Mieke Bal, Carol Meyers, Regina Schwartz, Naomi Steinberg). Particular attention is focused on the inclusion of Ruth within the Deuteronomic text in the LXX and Christian traditions.
Jobling, D. (1993). What, if anything, is 1 Samuel? Scandinavian Journal of the Old Testament. https://doi.org/10.1080/09018329308585003
Imported from OpenAlex (CC0) — nothing here is generated.