“Though Hermes never taught thee”: The Anti-Patriarchal Tendency of Charles Brockden Brown’s Mercurial Outcast Carwin, the Biloquist1

Abstract

In writing about early American gothic fiction, Cathy N. Davidson has explained that "the struggling individual has, in the Gothic world, a remarkable potential for good but an equally powerful motivation (and opportunity) for corruption" (Davidson 215).Over the past decades, the reputation of Carwin's narrative function in Charles Brockden Brown's Wieland (1798) and the subsequent "Memoirs of Carwin the Biloquist" (1803) and often discussed as a figure with a supporting role only, one of mystery, trickery or evil.Norman S. Grabo, for example, has interpreted Carwin as "a most shabby villain" and "the agent of stupid mischief rather than the engineer of evil" (Grabo 10).David Punter describes Carwin as "a rationalist friend of the family who claims to have been trying to teach Wieland a lesson in religious credulity" (Punter 167).Bill Christopherson finds Carwin to be "more red herring than protagonist" (Christopherson 34).Peter Kafer argues that "Carwin is just a mischievous wanderer with a special talent for projecting voices."He concludes: "while Carwin may be some sort of villain, there is nothing heroic about him" (Kafer 129).In Carwin's case, then, the interpretive stress has often lain on his potential to do evil.In light of Davidson's argument about the inherent ambiguity of early American gothic, it is also possible to read Carwin as an outsider figure, unknown to the protagonists in the Wieland, and consequently mysterious, but with "a remarkable potential for good."Ref?If Carwin is freed from his conceptual straightjacket as gothic villain and is placed in the context of alternative cultural schemata such as Hermetic philosophy, and utopian idealism, he becomes a figure of potential heroic dissidence, a radical individualist who "Though Hermes never taught thee": The Anti-Patriarchal Tendency of Charles B...

Cite this work

No public copy is stored for this record, so only the metadata is cited.

Stored only when both papers are in the corpus — 17 citations exist upstream.

Papers that cite the same references — the relational fallback while embeddings are still backfilling.