No open-access location is known for this record yet.
No open-access location is known for this record yet.
A MACULIST AT THE COURT OF ALFONSO EL SABIO: GIL DE ZAMORA'S LOST TREATISE ON THE IMMACULATE CONCEPTION Thirteenth-century Spain had four outstanding singers of the Blessed Virgin Mary: Gonzalo de Berceo, Raymon Llull, Alfonso the Wise, and Gil de Zamora. Of these, the mariology of Berceo and Llull has been the object of discussion,1 whereas there are no substantial treatments of that of Alfonso and Gil. This means that the history of the Immaculate Conception remains to be written for thirteenth century Spain. For Berceo, in spite of the texts cited and the conclusions drawn by García Garcés, we can affirm that he took no position on the Immaculate Conception in the manuscripts which have come down to us.2 Alfonso the Tenth, usually called Alfonso el Sabio, 1221-84, king of Castille and León (1252-84), is well-known as a scholar-king who left behind many scientific treatises, but he is best known as the author of the Cantigas, a series of songs in praise of the BVM, undoubtedly the best suite of songs in her honor from the Middle Ages.3 In spite of the fact that his best-known work is on Mary, and his pious devotion to her is a commonplace of scholarship, little has been done on his mariology. Given his erudition, one must expect 1 Cf. P. Narciso García Garcés, C.M.F., "Doctrina Mariana en la poesía de Gonzalo de Berceo," Studia mediaevalia et mariologica, P. Carolo BaM OFM septuagesimum explenti annum dicata, ed. P. Robertus Zavalloni, O.F.M. (Rome, 1971), 621-641, especially pp. 627-630, "María, inmaculada." Bartolomé Salva, "B. Raymundus Lullus et eius doctrina de immaculata conceptione, Textus lulliani," ATO, II (1934), 170-72. Of course, we have used the splendid article by X. Ie Bachelet, "Immaculée Conception," art. in Dictionnaire de Théologie Catholique , t. VII, 2, 845-1218. 2 For more information on Berceo's mariology, see particularly Víctor García de la Concha, "Los Loores de Nuestra Sennora, un 'Compendium historiae salutis'," Berceo, nos. 94-95 (1972), 133-189. 8 John E. Keller, Alfonso X, El Sabio (New York, 1967). 172JOHN W. MARCHAND and SPURGEON W. BALDWIN him to have followed the major theological trends of the day related to the Virigin, and it should surprise no one to learn that he was clearly a Maculist. In the Cantigas he subscribed to the theory that Mary was sanctified in the womb, after the moment of conception:4 310.6 ff. Ca sempre santivigadaFor she was immediately sanctified foi des que a fez seu padrea soon as her father made her eno corpo de sa madre.in the body of her mother. 411. 14 ff. E logo que foi viva no corpoAnd as soon as she was alive in the de sa madre,body of her mother, foi quita do pecado que Adán,She was freed from the sin which nosso padre fezera...Adam, our father, committed... In fact, Alfonso subscribed to the same form of sanctification theory seen in St. Bonaventure, according to which Mary was sanctified also after her biith: 330.2 f. A santivigadaThe one sanctified, ant'e de pois que foi nada.Before and after she was born. It might be natural to suppose that he must have gotten these opinions from his spiritual advisor, Gil de Zamora, but until now evidence as to Gil's position on the Immaculate Conception has not been available. Our knowledge of Gil's mariology came from materials published in the last century by Fidel Fita, and Fita had based his work on Ms. Bb 150 of the Biblioteca Nacional in Madrid, from which the four leaves dealing with the Immaculate Conception had been excised.8 Given Gil's fondness for the Helsinus episode (to which he refers at least three times in his Liber Mariae, or Life of Mary), his position in the Franciscan Order, and his belief in the pre-existence of Mary, it was logical to suppose him to have been an Immaculist, and Fita's reference to Torquemada and Alva indicates that he felt Gil to have been...
Loading…
Stored only when both papers are in the corpus — 3 citations exist upstream.
Imported from OpenAlex (CC0) — nothing here is generated.