envelope, you are then given the opportunity to change to the other envelope. Given that your objective is to maximize your wealth, should you refuse the offer or swap envelopes? Suppose the amount of the cheque in the chosen envelope is x. Then the other envelope contains either x/2 or 2x, and these two possibilities are equally likely. It follows that the expected value of the cheque in the other envelope is (0.5 x x/2) + (0.5 x 2x) = 1.25x. So it seems that you should swap because the other envelope will on average contain a larger sum. But it also seems that this conclusion must be false. For there can be no way of deducing some advantage in choosing one envelope over another without some information about the contents of the envelopes, in addition to the fact that the cheque in one envelope is twice the value of the cheque in the other. Choosing one envelope cannot put you in the position of reasonably expecting that the other contains more, for had you chosen the other envelope first the same argument would lead you to the opposite conclusion.1 In this paper we will indicate certain shortcomings in earlier assessments of the stated paradox and present a revised version of the paradox for which swapping envelopes is the best option. We will be concerned throughout with the possibility of a probabilistic argument in favour of swapping envelopes. The argument for swapping envelopes requires that, whatever amount x is in the envelope you pick first, you are equally likely to find x/2 or 2x in
Scott, A. and Scott, M. (1997). What's in the Two Envelope Paradox? Analysis. https://doi.org/10.1111/1467-8284.00048
Imported from OpenAlex (CC0) — nothing here is generated.