No open-access location is known for this record yet.
No open-access location is known for this record yet.
Previous articleNext article FreeFrom Tarporley to Dolon: The Reattribution of the Early South Italian “New York Goose Vase”Martine Denoyelle, and Francesca SilvestrelliMartine DenoyelleScientific Adviser, Institut National d’Histoire de l’Art, Paris Search for more articles by this author , and Francesca SilvestrelliLecturer in Classical Archaeology, University of Salento, Lecce Search for more articles by this author PDFPDF PLUSFull Text Add to favoritesDownload CitationTrack CitationsPermissionsReprints Share onFacebookTwitterLinked InRedditEmailQR Code SectionsMoreThe red figure calyx-krater in The Metropolitan Museum of Art heretofore attributed to the Tarporley Painter and said to have been found in Ruvo has always been considered essential for studies of the spread of comic theater in Magna Graecia (Figures 1, 2, 7, 8, 10).1 Generally dated about 400 B.C. or shortly after, it is the first extant South Italian vase to show a comic performance in an explicit theatrical context, indicated by the presence of the stage at the right of the image on the obverse. It has long been thought to be at the head of a figurative tradition recognized as peculiar to Apulian workshops and, to a lesser extent, to South Italian workshops generally. As summed up by Arthur Dale Trendall in his Early South Italian Vase-Painting, “The New York krater is of great importance as the first of what is destined to be a long series of Apulian phlyax vases.”2 The word “phlyax” traditionally designates a type of comic actor or play very popular in southern Italy that is depicted in vase painting from the end of the fifth century B.C. onward. The scene on the obverse of this calyx-krater, commonly interpreted as the punishment of a thief, illustrates one of these comic performances (Figure 1). On the right, an old woman on a stage, with a dead goose and a basket containing two kid goats at her feet, is vehemently addressing two figures in the orchestra. These are an old man standing on tiptoe, his arms stretched high over his head as if he were chained, and a policeman with long hair watching over him. At the far left, a nude youth, his mantle slung over his left shoulder, stands on a wavy line that indicates higher ground (Figure 7). A mask hangs in the background. Inscriptions that seem to issue from the figures’ mouths transcribe the dialogues among the actors.1. Calyx-krater, attributed to the Tarporley Painter, here attributed to the Dolon Painter. South Italian, Lucanian, ca. 400–390 B.C. Terracotta, H. 12 in. (30.6 cm), Diam. 12½ in. (31.8 cm). Side A, a comic play. The Metropolitan Museum of Art, Fletcher Fund, 1924 (24.97.104). Photograph: Paul Lachenauer, The Photograph Studio, MMA2. Side B of Figure 1, draped youthsThe vase is notable in many respects: the originality of the composition, the vivid realism of the drawing with the characters’ lively gesticulation, the identity of the comic play performed, and, above all, the presence of the inscriptions.3 All these elements have given it a fame reflected in such appellations as the “New York Phlyax Vase” or the “New York Goose Vase” (an allusion to the object of the conflict depicted).Leaving aside the well-studied question regarding the interpretation of the play and its origins,4 this article presents arguments for a reattribution of the krater from the Apulian Tarporley Painter to the Lucanian Dolon Painter. The point may initially appear a subsidiary one, but changing from an Apulian painter to a Lucanian one affects our views about the artistic identity of both schools and their roles in shaping the iconography of Greek comic theater.5 This reattribution also sheds fresh light on the careers of both painters, which have not been reconsidered since Trendall’s study of them, published forty years ago, although archaeology has provided new information especially on the find contexts of these artists’ vases and those of their associates.The Tarporley Painter, whose name piece is a fine bell-krater in the Los Angeles County Museum of Art (Figures 3, 4),6 owes his name to the place of residence of the bell-krater’s onetime owner, the Honorable Marshall Brooks, in Tarporley, Cheshire, England. The Tarporley Painter is the leading figure in the development of Apulian vase painting at the beginning of the first quarter of the fourth century B.C. A pupil of the Sisyphus Painter, whose influence is reflected in his early works, he pioneered the so-called Plain Style, dominated by Dionysiac and “genre” scenes, which prevailed in Apulian production for nearly half a century.7 His taste for the Dionysiac world in all its aspects is clear from such serene scenes as the one on the obverse of the Los Angeles bell-krater (Figure 3), in which a maenad crowns Dionysos in the presence of a young Pan holding a bird. Other vases include satyrs and such theatrical elements as masks and chorus men.8 The Los Angeles bell-krater was placed by Trendall in the painter’s early phase, characterized by the “Sisyphean,” solemn attitudes of the figures and the drawing of the profiles with a wide-open eye;9 the nude male bodies are slender and graceful. The youths on the reverse show some typical features, like the “inverted squiggly Y” in the lower part of the central youth’s cloak—which occurs also on vases by some members of his close circle10—or the bare chest and right shoulder of the rightmost youth and the bare left shoulder of the youth on the left. Belonging to the same period, a bell-krater in Sydney with three actors who are probably preparing to perform in a satyr play has two figures standing with their masks in hand and one, on the right, already fully dressed as a satyr (Figure 5).11 Here again, the compact but supple bodies of the youths are typical of the Tarporley Painter, as are the actors’ profile heads, with the straight lines joining foreheads and noses and with somewhat heavy chins.3. Bell-krater, attributed to the Tarporley Painter. South Italian, Apulian, ca. 400–390 B.C. Terracotta, H. 14¾ in. (37.5 cm), Diam. 14⅝ in. (37.2 cm). Side A, Dionysos with a maenad and Pan. Los Angeles County Museum of Art, William Randolph Hearst Collection (50.8.29). Photograph: David Galley4. Side B of Figure 3, draped youths. Photograph: David Galley5. Bell-krater, attributed to the Tarporley Painter. South Italian, Apulian, ca. 400–390 B.C. Terracotta, H. 13 in. (33 cm), Diam. of mouth 14⅛ in. (36 cm). Side A, actors of a satyr play. The Nicholson Museum, The University of Sydney (NM 47.5). Photograph: from Cambitoglou and Turner 2008, pl. 2The New York calyx-krater, by contrast, having been placed by Trendall among the Tarporley Painter’s “earliest work,” would have been created and decorated before the Los Angeles and Sydney examples and under even stronger influence of the Sisyphus Painter.12 In Trendall’s characterization of this phase, typical features include nude youths standing and holding out a bird or an object, small heads on the figures with details accurately drawn, the “inverted squiggly Y” for the black borders of the draperies, which on the obverse are sometimes also decorated with dots. None of these features occurs on the calyx-krater, even though the stance and the draping of the youths on the reverse broadly recall the Tarporley Painter’s manner. Nor is the Sisyphus Painter’s influence obvious,13 even in the figure of the bare-chested youth on the reverse, whose cloak is arranged differently from the representative examples of the same period.14Several reasons may explain why the attribution of such a well-published masterpiece has never been scrutinized. First, as publications have always focused on the puzzling image on the main side of the vase, they consistently neglected—often even failed to reproduce—the decoration on the reverse. Second, stylistic analysis of a comic representation is difficult, since figures usually do not provide sufficient anatomical or physiognomic clues to characterize the style of a painter.Instead, both sides of the New York vase offer convincing comparisons with features that occur frequently in the Dolon Painter’s work. Along with a similar conception of the anatomy (for example, the drawing of the breasts, belly, and pubic hair), the costumes of the two male actors find close parallels with the one worn by the phlyax on the fragmentary skyphos from deposit 1 of the potters’ quarter at Metaponto (Figure 6).15 Common to these figures is the absence of a short tunic, which becomes more usual in later Middle Comedy, and the way the frontal padding is rendered as an artificial element added to the costume; the New York krater also clearly shows the buckle used to fasten the frontal padding.166. Fragmentary skyphos, attributed to the Dolon Painter. South Italian, Lucanian, from discard deposit no. 1 at Metaponto, ca. 400–390 B.C. Terracotta, H. 4⅞ in. (12.3 cm), Diam. of rim 5½ in. (14 cm), Diam. of base 4 in. (10.1 cm). Side A, a comic actor. Museo Archeologico Nazionale, Metaponto (29062). Photograph: © Ministero per i Beni e le Attività Culturali—Direzione Regionale per i Beni Culturali e Paesaggistici della Basilicata—Soprintendenza per i Beni Archeologici della BasilicataAt the far left of the obverse of the New York vase, the naked youth with a folded cloak over his left shoulder assumes a static pose that contrasts with the postures of the other characters (Figure 7). His identity remains under debate, and he is often described as a spectator.17 Whatever his role, he is standing on a rocky prominence rendered by lightly incised lines, and he does not really seem to watch the performance. His presence may have a more allusive than realistic significance, possibly explained by the inscription at his midsection (rather than issuing from his mouth), ΤΡΑΓΩΙΔΟΣ (tragic actor), which is meant to define his function in the image.7. Detail of side A of Figure 1, a youth with the inscription ΤΡΑΓΩΙΔΟΣEven though it may not be evident at first glance, this figure finds parallels in works of the Dolon Painter, particularly in the youths on the reverse of vases of the so-called Tardol Period,18 and in figures decorating small vessels, such as the woman at the louterion on a pelike in Taranto.19 On the New York krater, the relative proportions of the youth’s head to his body, the drawing of the head in profile with the pointed nose and small chin, and the lines that mark the transition from the torso to the legs are very characteristic of the Dolon Painter’s work.The youths on the reverse of the New York krater also provide sound clues for this reattribution (Figure 2). When comparing them to the pure Tarporley style, as illustrated on the Los Angeles name piece (Figure 4), one can note similarities in stance and drapery: the youth on the right of the New York piece, for instance, with his bare chest and raised right arm, is clearly inspired by a Tarporleyan type. But details such as folds and borders of the garments differ significantly; moreover, the hairstyles and physiognomies are different and are much closer to those of the Dolon Painter. The shape of the heads, the slightly curved pupils of the eyes, the pronounced chins, and the half-open mouths appear on the figures of such vases as the hydria from the Metaponto discard deposit no. 1.20 The way the youth on the right holds his stick with his index finger raised as well as the drawing of his massive hand are paralleled on several vases by the Dolon Painter such as a stemmed dish in Saint Petersburg, a calyx-krater in Cambridge, and both sides of the Odysseus calyx-krater in the Cabinet des Médailles in Paris.21Some secondary elements may also reinforce the connection between the New York calyx-krater and works by the Dolon Painter. Behind the old woman standing on the stage, the facade of a building is rendered with a roof and a pediment supported by two Ionic columns framing a closed door (Figure 8). The upper panels of the doors are decorated in black figure with a satyr and a woman apparently dancing. This piece of architecture may be compared with the fountain at which Athena washes her hands before the Judgment of Paris on the calyx-krater in the Cabinet des Médailles (Figure 9): that is a small, square structure seen in three-quarter view, with three ionic columns (the fourth is hidden) and, on the back wall, two plaques suspended beneath two lion’s-head mascarons spitting water.8. Detail of side A of Figure 1, the old woman on the stage9. Calyx-krater, attributed to the Dolon Painter. South Italian, Lucanian, ca. 390 B.C. Terracotta, H. 19⅛ in. (48.5 cm), Diam. of rim 19⅛ in. (48.5 cm), Diam. of base 8⅞ in. (22.6 cm). Detail of side B, Athena at the fountain. Bibliothèque Nationale de France, Paris, Département des Monnaies, Médailles, et Antiques (422). Photograph: © Bibliothèque Nationale de FranceThe spirit is the same as that of the New York krater, for not only do we find exactly the same columns, with a palmette ornament below the capital of each, but the volutes of each capital are centered with a small round dot of brown gloss. This tiny but important technical feature22 is frequently used by the Dolon Painter to render details as various as the pupils of Dolon’s own eyes on his name vase in the British Museum23 and the left nipple of the thief on the New York krater (Figure 1). The brownish dilute gloss, visible on the borders of the draperies, for example, is extensively used by the painter, in contrast with the practice of the Tarporley Painter. Other technical features, such as the area above each handle of the New York krater that was hastily covered with a thin layer of reddish gloss, are also frequently found on vases of the Dolon Painter’s workshop.These elements are as significant for the attribution as the expressive, highly personal drawing, particularly in the Dolon Painter’s Dionysiac scenes. The originality of his composition and his gestural language, already noted,24 is typical of him and contrasts with the quiet and classical creations of the Tarporley Painter.The shape of the New York vase is that of a calyx-krater, which, with its extensive and almost vertical walls, is particularly suitable for complex compositions. It has an almost squarish body, handles turned sharply inward at their tops, while at the base they join a low and slightly concave belly. It diverges substantially from the Dolon Painter’s other known calyx-kraters (Figure 10). The vase in the Cabinet des Médailles, the largest and most impressive of his calyx-kraters, is noteworthy for its slender profile and low belly.25 Other vases are characterized by the straight, vertical handles and a very rounded and high belly, a shape clearly exemplified by the vessels in Cambridge and London,26 and also adopted for examples produced in the potter’s quarter at Metaponto.27 The New York calyx-krater bears some resemblance to vessels attributed to the Amykos Painter,28 to the Schwerin Group,29 and to the so-called Forerunners,30 as well as to kraters by the Tarporley Painter.31 Nonetheless, its proportions are unusual, making it rather inelegant and heavy-looking. The peculiarities in the krater’s shape are not an obstacle in attributing the vessel to the Dolon Painter, however, for he decorated a large range of shapes, apparently made by different potters. But the New York krater’s shape does not provide decisive clues for the identification of the workshop.10. Profile drawings of calyx-kraters attributed to the Dolon Painter. (1) Bibliothèque Nationale de France, Paris, Département des Monnaies, Médailles, et Antiques (422), H. 19⅛ in. (48.5 cm); see Figure 9. (2) The Metropolitan Museum of Art (24.97.104), H. 12 in. (30.6 cm); see Figures 1, 2. (3) British Museum, London (F 157), H. 19¾ in. (50 cm). (4) Fitzwilliam Museum, Cambridge (GR 70/1970), H. 15¾ in. (40.1 cm). Drawings: Caroline Florimont (1), Elizabeth Wahle (2), Kate Morton (3), Aurelia Masson (4). Composite of drawings: Elizabeth WahleAlthough the change of attribution may seem unexpected owing to the fame of the New York vase, it originates in a stylistic ambiguity between the work of the two painters that has been pointed out repeatedly by Trendall and is reflected in the so-called Tardol Group; this acronym, made up from the painters’ names, represents the period when the Dolon Painter worked in a style that closely imitated that of the Tarporley Painter.32 This in Trendall’s at the end of the Tarporley Painter’s and at the beginning of the Dolon Painter’s we up to about the of the of these two vase painters on the one on Trendall’s and, on the on finds at On the of an already extant of South Italian Trendall considered the Tarporley Painter to be Apulian, he to the tradition of the Painter of the and the Sisyphus Painter. to the that this production in is very for several As for the Lucanian in which he placed the Dolon Painter in his of and he its at Metaponto in in the to that of the discard found in the potters’ quarter of the the of the two the of Trendall’s of the early development of South Italian vase This would that the Dolon Painter’s would have place in for between the Tarporley Painter and the Dolon Painter can be on a bell-krater in a published by and attributed by him to the Tardol (Figures Here the of the two painters are found side by we are not with stylistic or but with between the Dolon and the Tarporley The bell-krater is decorated on both sides with and on each two figures can be attributed to the Dolon Painter and the other two to the Tarporley Painter. The anatomy and the conception of the two on the left of the obverse (Figure characterized by their massive find parallels in figures typical of the Dolon while the two on the right, with more can be to some figures of the Tarporley Bell-krater, attributed to the Tardol South Italian, ca. 400–390 B.C. Terracotta, H. in. cm), Diam. 15¾ in. cm). Side A, Photograph: from 2008, Side B of Figure draped youths. Photograph: from 2008, the reverse, the draped youths can be two each by a different hand (Figure The two youths on the left are by the Tarporley typical of his work are the wavy of the cloak worn by the right youth, as well as his chest the rightmost youth in Figure The head of the left youth and the proportions of his are characteristic as The two on the right are draped youths who can be compared to and of Trendall’s The type youth, seen from the back and in although also used by the Tarporley occurs more frequently on vases by the Dolon Trendall’s type can be compared the youth from the right, although his stance is more subsidiary decoration with the below the in vases of this period, is on a by both the Dolon and the Tarporley The is by the Tarporley shape of the bell-krater published by from those decorated by the Dolon Painter, which are characterized by an almost vertical rim and and whose can be back to the shape adopted by the and Amykos example, by contrast, presents an rim and a straight body, which can also be found on other by the Tarporley Painter and, by the Sisyphus the shape to be more with the tradition of the Tarporley Painter and the painter here for the subsidiary decoration of the be considered in early South Italian Along with the to the Painter and to the for between painters in the same is a in on which the reverse is by the Painter, while the obverse can be attributed to the In all these we are not with stylistic we are also the of work in the of this two the New York calyx-krater and the bell-krater in a new on the relative of the two As the bell-krater the figures that can be attributed to the Tarporley Painter the by Trendall as typical of his the holding a in his left hand one of the figures used in vases of his early phase, a figure that is in the Dolon Painter’s even if each figure the of the the two each holding a round and a are closer to in the Dolon Painter’s early a in our the Tardol phase, whose relative on stylistic analysis owing to the
Loading…
Stored only when both papers are in the corpus — 22 citations exist upstream.
Imported from OpenAlex (CC0) — nothing here is generated.