Study
Works
By typeArticlesJournal papersBooksMonographs & volumesBook chaptersSections & contributionsDatasetsResearch dataDissertationsTheses & PhD workPreprintsBefore peer review
AccessOpen accessGold, diamond, hybrid, greenReadable herePDF stored in this libraryBangladesh-affiliatedBD institutional researchDiscoverAll worksFull catalogue · filter & sortSearchFull-text & metadata
Subjects
4 domains · 252 subfieldsFull directory →
Social Sciences
AnthropologyLibrary and Information SciencesGeneral Social SciencesUrban StudiesPublic AdministrationGeography, Planning and DevelopmentGender StudiesDemographyTransportationSociology and Political ScienceAll Social Sciences →
Physical Sciences
Information SystemsComputer Vision and Pattern RecognitionComputer Networks and CommunicationsArtificial IntelligenceHuman-Computer InteractionComputer Science ApplicationsComputational Theory and MathematicsSignal ProcessingHardware and ArchitectureSoftwareAll Physical Sciences →
Life Sciences
General Agricultural and Biological SciencesPlant ScienceFood ScienceSoil ScienceEcology, Evolution, Behavior and SystematicsAgronomy and Crop ScienceForestryInsect ScienceAquatic ScienceHorticultureAll Life Sciences →
Health Sciences
Radiological and Ultrasound TechnologyGeneral Health ProfessionsSpeech and HearingPharmacyEmergency Medical ServicesPhysical Therapy, Sports Therapy and RehabilitationHealth Information ManagementMedical TerminologyComplementary and Manual TherapyOccupational TherapyAll Health Sciences →
BrowseSearch
Study

An open academic library built on OpenAlex metadata (CC0). Browse, search, and read millions of research works.

ExploreBrowse shelvesSearch worksOpen accessReadable here
AccountDashboardMy library
Study · ZodixMetadata: OpenAlex CC0
ArticleShelves
ArticleInnateness and the instinct to learn
Peter Marler2004
OA
Articlediamond2004

Innateness and the instinct to learn

Peter Marler

60 citations·0/0 files stored·Anais da Academia Brasileira de Ciências

No readable copy stored yet — this record is metadata only.

Literature note
Philosophy and History of ScienceAnimal Behavior and ReproductionAnimal Vocal Communication and Behavior

Abstract

Concepts of innateness were at the heart of Darwin's approach to behavior and central to the ethological theorizing of Lorenz and, at least to start with, of Tinbergen. Then Tinbergen did an about face, and for some twenty years the term 'innate' became highly suspect. He attributed the change to Lehrman's famous 1953 critique in which he asserted that classifying behaviors as innate tells us nothing about how they develop. Although Lehrman made many valid points, I will argue that this exchange also led to profound misunderstandings that were ultimately damaging to progress in research on the development of behavior. The concept of 'instincts to learn', receiving renewed support from current theorizing among geneticists about phenotypic plasticity, provides a potential resolution of some of the controversies that Lehrman created. Bioacoustical studies, particularly on song learning in birds, serve both to confirm some of Lehrman's anxieties about the term 'innate', but also to make a case that he threw out the genetic baby with the bathwater. The breathtaking progress in molecular and developmental genetics has prepared the way for a fuller understanding of the complexities underlying even the simplest notions of innate behavior, necessary before we can begin to comprehend the ontogeny of behavior.

Cite this work

Marler, P. (2004). Innateness and the instinct to learn. Anais da Academia Brasileira de Ciências. https://doi.org/10.1590/s0001-37652004000200002

No public copy is stored for this record, so only the metadata is cited.

Details

Year2004
Typearticle
Published2004-06-01
VenueAnais da Academia Brasileira de Ciências
ISSN-L0001-3765
Languageen
Citations60
Files0 public / 0
ShelfPhilosophy and History of Science

Identifiers

doi10.1590/s0001-37652004000200002
openalex_workW2111663168

Links

doiopen

Imported from OpenAlex (CC0) — nothing here is generated.

pdfopen