Prologue: Recent studies have determined that more than half of all homicides in this country involve drugs or alcohol; furthermore, alcohol and drugs are implicated in an even larger proportion of nonfatal violent acts. Given the public health community's increased interest in violence and its toll on society, the linkage between substances and violence seems a logical next step. Indeed, as Jeffrey Fagan writes in this paper, hundreds of complex interactions exist among these phenomena. While experts agree that drugs and alcohol often play a role in violent activities, their precise role is less clear. Here Fagan discusses the limitations and dilemmas of current research into interactions among drugs, alcohol, and violence, based on an expanding literature in this field. Several issues in law and social science “complicate efforts to explain the relationships between substance use and interpersonal violence,” Fagan writes. These issues include the inability to establish firm causation in substance-related violent acts; the legal status of drugs and complications involving trafficking and law enforcement; difficulties in separating environments or individual traits of substance users from their violent behavior; disagreement on how to measure the prevalence and precise correlates of violence and substance abuse; and problems constructing research paradigms. “The weight of evidence suggests that substance use provides a provocative context for violence,” Fagan writes, “but there is limited evidence that alcohol or drugs directly cause violence.” Fagan is an associate professor in the School of Criminal Justice, S.I. Newhouse Center for Law and Justice, at Rutgers University in Newark, New Jersey. He received his doctorate in policy science from the Department of Civil Engineering, State University of New York (SUNY) at Buffalo and holds a master's degree in human factors engineering also from SUNY Buffalo. Abstract: This paper identifies five research dilemmas in associating violence with substance abuse: (1) difficulty in establishing causal linkages; (2) problems associated with the legal status of substances; (3) ecological and individualistic fallacies; (4) measurement issues and problems with data sources; and (5) research design problems. The author then discusses social context and the role of rational choice as frameworks to explain the interaction among drugs, alcohol, and violence.
Fagan, J. (1993). Interactions Among Drugs, Alcohol, and Violence. Health Affairs. https://doi.org/10.1377/hlthaff.12.4.65
Imported from OpenAlex (CC0) — nothing here is generated.