No open-access location is known for this record yet.
No open-access location is known for this record yet.
James F. Crow is Professor Emeritus of Genetics at the University of Wisconsin–Madison. He was born in Philadelphia, grew up in Wichita, Kansas, did graduate work at the University of Texas–Austin (PhD 1941), taught at Dartmouth College, and since 1948 has been on the faculty of the University of Wisconsin. He has honorary doctorates from the Universities of Chicago and Edinburgh. He is a member of the National Academy of Science, National Academy of Medicine, and American Philosophical Society. He is a foreign member of the Japan Academy and the Royal Society of London. He is past president of the Genetics Society of America and the American Society of Human Genetics. His research has been in theoretical and experimental population genetics. He has written a number of articles and three books—Genetics Notes, Basic Concepts in Population, Quantitative, and Evolutionary Genetics, and Introduction to Population Genetics Theory (with M. Kimura). His hobby is music, and for many years he played viola in the Madison Symphony Orchestra. 2003 is the centennial year of the American Genetic Association, and what a century this has been! 1903 was a banner year in the history of genetics. This was the year in which Sutton published his famous paper putting together chromosome behavior and Mendel's laws (Sutton 1903). This can be regarded as the beginning of genetics as a science. 1903 was also the year in which the American Breeders Association was founded. This soon became the American Genetic Association (AGA), and in 1914 the AGA began publication of the Journal of Heredity. The century, 1903–2003, ushered in by these two events, has seen genetics grow from very modest beginnings into a powerful science that permeates throughout biology. My intention in this lecture is to trace the history of the subject by citing articles that have appeared over these years in the two publications of the AGA. Although founded in 1903, the AGA did not have a regular publication until 1910, when the American Breeders Magazine started. This continued through 1913, and in 1914 changed its name to the Journal of Heredity. During my childhood in the 1920s, my father subscribed to this journal and I enjoyed looking at it. The main attraction was the pictures, some of which came vividly back to mind recently as I looked through old issues. So my association with the AGA began a long time ago and still continues. It is a pleasure to talk about it. The new journal began, not with a whimper, but with a bang. The first article was written by Alexander Graham Bell, famous for having invented the telephone some 40 years earlier. Bell had a deep interest in heredity, especially inheritance of deafness. He had astutely noticed the high rate of consanguinity among normal parents of the deaf. As were a great many students of heredity at the time, Bell was interested in eugenics. His leadoff article was entitled, “How to Improve the Human Race.” Bell argued that there was little to be gained by preventing marriage of “undesirables;” he believed that assortative mating among the better endowed was much more important. Inventing the telephone was only one part of his active life. He produced all sorts of inventions, including an electric device for locating metal in human tissue. It was used to locate the bullet after President Garfield was assassinated. Bell had a deep interest in livestock breeding and tried to develop a strain of sheep with a high rate of twinning. (This was long before the Booroola gene was discovered.) In addition to his passion for genetics and invention, Bell had a deep interest in geography and was president of the National Geographic Society. His son in law, Gilbert Grosvenor, became assistant editor of the National Geographic Magazine in 1899 and editor 4 years later. While editor, he built its circulation from 900 to 2 million. I think it is fair to say that he was the founder of photojournalism and the magazine soon became known for its vivid photographs. Sewall Wright once told me that Bell also hoped for an equally popular magazine devoted to genetics, and thought of another son in law, David Fairchild, as one to take the lead. Apparently nothing came of this at the time, but a few years later Fairchild was president of the AGA when the Journal of Heredity started. He was a distinguished botanist and, while working for the U.S. Department of Agriculture, was responsible for the introduction of thousands of plant species. Both Bell and Fairchild were members of the Council of the AGA. The only other member who is known to present-day geneticists was William Castle, who was vice president. Of course, Journal of Heredity never attained the popularity of National Geographic, but it held its own among scientific journals and quickly became known for its lively style and photographs. The first editor was Paul Popenoe. Popenoe was widely known among American animal breeders and students of heredity. Journal of Heredity reflected his enthusiasm for the now-controversial subject of eugenics. As late as 1938, while a graduate student at the University of Texas, I heard him lecture on the subject. He was an enthusiastic and charismatic advocate, but by then the American eugenics movement was in rapid decline. Later he became a marriage counselor and newspaper columnist. The Wilhelmine Key Lectures began in 1962 with a gift from Dr. Key. She is best known for being the teacher of Sewall Wright. She encouraged him to read Punnett's article on genetics in the Encyclopedia Britannica. She was enthusiastic about research and opened his mind to the possibility of doing research. He often said that he owed a great deal to her. The two communicated throughout her life. She expressed admiration for his work, but rued her inability to understand his mathematics. Wilhelmine Enteman was born in 1872 and grew up in Wisconsin. She attended the University of Wisconsin and as an undergraduate worked with the pioneer limnologist, E. A. Birge. After graduation in 1894, she taught in Green Bay for 4 years and then became a graduate student at the University of Chicago. There she worked with C. O. Whitman and was especially impressed by C. B. Davenport. After her doctorate she taught biology and nature study at New Mexico Normal. At about this time she married Francis B. Key, a descendant of Francis Scott Key. The marriage was short lived, however, for her husband was an invalid and did not survive long. She then taught at Belmont College and finally went to Lombard College in 1909. It was during his senior year in 1910–1911 that Wright came under her influence. In 1912 she left to rejoin Davenport, who by that time was in the Eugenics Record Office at Cold Spring Harbor, New York. Later she moved to the Race Betterment Foundation in Battle Creek, Michigan. She was deeply interested in human betterment and soon was active as a field worker. She wrote a number of articles on eugenics, some in Journal of Heredity. I have the impression that, in contrast to many early eugenicists, she was less of an advocate and more of a student. For more about her see Wright (1965). As I mentioned earlier, genetics as a science began in 1903 when Walter Sutton (Figure 1) showed that meiotic chromosomes follow a behavior pattern that is consistent with Mendel's laws. Actually he was on the track a year earlier when he concluded an article on grasshopper chromosomes with the statement: “I may finally call attention to the probability that the association of paternal and maternal chromosomes in pairs and their subsequent separation during the reducing division...may constitute the physical basis of the Mendelian law of heredity” (Sutton 1902). Sutton's definitive paper, with his beautiful drawings of grasshopper chromosomes came soon after (Sutton 1903). Shortly after, the same idea was published by Boveri, who had thought of it independently. I think it likely that several biologists realized this, but it was Sutton and Boveri who presented the convincing evidence. Sutton grew up on a Kansas farm known for its high-quality livestock. He demonstrated an inventive streak early in life by repairing farm equipment and making a camera. He attended the University of Kansas and there became a student of C. E. McClung, who encouraged Sutton to study the chromosomes of grasshoppers, which he collected on his farm. There was no shortage of grasshoppers in Kansas! It was his thorough knowledge of chromosome behavior that led to his happy insight. Sutton was clearly a favorite of McClung, and as far as I know, made only one mistake. At the time it was known that the male grasshopper has 23 chromosomes; it has an X and no Y. Sutton undertook the much more difficult task of determining the chromosome number in the female, and he counted 22 rather than the correct number, 24. Chromosome identification wasn't as easy in those days as it is now. This error led McClung to the conclusion that the X chromosome is male-determining. There was considerable confusion about sex chromosomes and sex linkage in those years. A further complication was that the early studies of sex linkage were done with moths, in which the female is heterogametic, whereas the chromosome studies were on insect species with heterogametic males. It was finally clarified by simultaneous cytological and genetic studies on Drosophila. Sutton dropped out of graduate school, probably for financial reasons, and went to work in the Kansas oil fields. There he continued his inventive ways, making several improvements in the drilling machinery. He eventually returned to school, but this time in medicine. He became a distinguished surgeon, and was just as inventive in this field as he had been in genetics and engineering (Crow and Crow 2002; McKusick 1960). For one thing, he was the first to use rectal anesthesia, necessary for facial surgery, and invented a “speedometer” to accurately measure the delivery rate. The articles in Journal of Heredity and its short-lived predecessor, American Breeders Magazine, provide a vivid view of the changing field of genetics during its first century. From the beginning the emphasis in these journals has been mainly on organismic genetics in a wide variety of animals and plants, and in the early years, on eugenics. I have compiled a list of topics covered during successive periods in the history of the AGA. It is certainly not a random sample, nor is it systematic. It simply reflects what seem to me to be interesting items characteristic of their period. They provide a series of snapshots of how genetics has grown and changed during its first century. Items reported as novel in the early days are now commonplace. Some early interpretations are now known to be wrong. An example is the sterility of tortoiseshell tomcats (see later). Cytogenetic explanations, now obvious, were overlooked in the early days. Counts of the human chromosome number were wrong for several years. Mutator genes seemed utterly mysterious; now they are usually caused by transposable elements. And of course, the methods have become increasingly biochemical and molecular over the years. Yet some of the earliest observations have stood the test of time. The effectiveness of selection for oil content in corn was already evident in the first as was of and for corn in the are still a in is still used to And is a list of topics that to me to their In the first there were of and was a for and led to his of A from the University of of selection for oil and in with at this early The which began before the of is still for and to corn this was done in not in the corn for in by were to be to reported on the early in his selection for of in reported that all in as the female is Apparently he sex articles on eugenics, the of the enthusiastic first editor, Paul Popenoe. of selection for of in Human as a in by as a possibility for livestock in in A series of articles by Sewall Wright on inheritance in They are of later articles to genetics. in and later in the by and their as animals for An normal for by (Figure the beginning of a new Genetics. this time, Journal of Heredity was the only American journal devoted to the American and articles on genetics. In contrast to Journal of which high-quality short and organismic Genetics was a journal of research. The first article was a paper on as of the chromosome of heredity. this time the was but the and a An Genetics and I were for I on time, but Genetics was a few The early years of Journal of Heredity were difficult Although the circulation in was and the some from the National Geographic it was still having making There was a series of articles on in which by this time was only to as a favorite for genetic research. Sewall Wright did a thorough of the genetic history of a number of of livestock. In several there were of tortoiseshell male It was realized that they were but their sterility was to maternal of course, that they are reported linkage of and in studies of were done in and used to genetic and cytological reported in but the possibility of a reported on this subject with in several subsequent years. of the to early used to in (Figure reported studies from several as the human chromosome and gene on reported in reported on The of produced as to was in the and was one reported genes in and later in which now be to and reported their of chromosomes in and of cytological reported on the in and reported their of the of They that was from an that, by with produced argued that was the of which has out to be reported on in the of to meiotic and a of It the knowledge for the later studies of and reported chromosome with a new for the study of this time on inheritance of the to reported on inheritance of on human were throughout of the Wright Theory of and the to and his own Although Wright and were at this time, their later became and was the of the early for 40 years (Figure His enthusiastic of eugenics had a on the which in the early years had a number of and on this including several by Wilhelmine Key. in genetics were He tried to a wide variety of and usually these were and He of human with Mendelian He to a variety of items of genetic and of as tortoiseshell He also enjoyed at (Figure and his of showed through (Figure His after the Genetic is of his of were in and to the is the but that is still in the may be He was and was two later. and reported on three methods of selection and concluded that selection is published more these the published a linkage of the X on an idea from that part of the X is with the Y. Although he came to the more recently and reported The idea that these be a to the was by the to with males. The had not reported that are is a that had a great and a number of physical into genetics. was not with research and that have been to also thought that inheritance in This is one the Mendelian genetics in A. and his used to and in this and An of in A paper by out a and chromosomes in This work in in which there are the and those with During the there was interest in two was and mainly to the of a new was in was the editor and the first article was by on selection in of Drosophila. At about the same time there was interest in human genetics. A was who was the first president of the American Society of Human Genetics. The American Journal of Human Genetics was by and the first in was by James on paper, of appeared in the The number of American journals in the field grew from one to in about a century. then there has been an of new that no of Sewall Wright told me that at one time he read article in the field of genetics. It was a in those days. The emphasis on eugenics is in on This was a for for the of his life. caused by a gene that is It was that there had been human selection for of their in the same pattern as that there is a that when but when A new of was it was to be especially for in the A devoted to The This was the first of several a but caused by a were of their human later and now popular research (Figure over the the subject of eugenics was The changed view is reflected in this from a task of human genetics is to of the of human as to the of the The journal a and more photographs. chromosomes in the is to be in a number of article on by now editor for Journal of Heredity. The high of among There were about human The can the chromosomes be distinguished only into Human in those days great with it is in in A chromosome of the later the basis for of in A article on the at for was in the journal by for for were for an article on and on become more An example of in a also to articles on genetics. male produced by from with males. and of and for number in produced and by is in are increasingly in Drosophila. The journal has now become a journal of research. are especially on the The research reported is increasingly with more emphasis on molecular There are still but there is a new on to human Population of an interest in other than Drosophila. in in A chromosome in in a for a human Genetic and of in in of in in in genetics in inheritance in of and meiotic in of linkage in and The molecular in A selection caused by a Mutator genes in the journal has been by At the same time, University over the The by to this a journal of research has Although there is still an emphasis on genetics, the journal has much to the of genetic with a of and genetics. I there are many that no The founded in 1903, has with the science of genetics through its with Sutton's of the basis of heredity the same As I have by through the of American Breeders Magazine and Journal of Heredity one can follow the main in the history of the subject. AGA journals usually have not reported new in of genetics, biochemical genetics, molecular population genetics, and other up to the of the and molecular have been published The AGA while on have more often been They have been of great in the to other species and the of new The journal has a of the of new usually with and by and in lively Although one read the more journals and nothing of the of the new their their and these were not by of Journal of Heredity. The past century has been one of in genetics. The subject now permeates all of and and in more and more of all research now the of genetics. this that genetics, by its very has widely that it has its be by this I to be than other genetics has been the of the two of the century, and In the early with its eugenics, Journal of Heredity was of this changed with the of Journal of Heredity its of the and the of genetics It was a to up with the in In its early years and through much of its Journal of Heredity was a of and for eugenics. The subject began with Francis and was on as an for the human It was a science and an who is often for his and genetic that eugenics was a science. Popenoe and were and Journal of Heredity reflected In the journal published a of the and the famous of of are was in eugenics looked to The emphasis was on changing There was a to probably no more than genetics is in some The of was And some were regarded as genetic when there was little for There was but not for the and of the Eugenics was in which the is to some on one on the the of the In addition to genetic there was the that parents not provide a for Yet for all its the movement was at best and at A number of geneticists the eugenics and probably a number were simply A few it. among these was (Crow The movement eventually its by its in At by and has from to now less attention to in the and more to the and of the The is for the and the rather than In one the to be of the of the and the of are the A not a and not the and of for it. So the is much less than in earlier is more it is still is better than Of course, this is not it is better to than to gene for It be less to a gene for than one for short there is a likely genetic methods be used for less and less there much by and the same by gene the from I think it is that as become more a
Loading…
Stored only when both papers are in the corpus — 8 citations exist upstream.
Imported from OpenAlex (CC0) — nothing here is generated.