When I began working on my dissertation on Kant's aesthetic theory in 1971, I was able to read virtually all of the extant literature on the Critique of Judgment in English, German, and French going back to Hermann Cohen's Kants Begründung der Ästhetik of 1889, while also reading most of what I wanted to read of eighteenth‐century British and German aesthetics before Kant—not because I had paid my dues to Evelyn Wood, but just because there was not all that much to read.1 I pity the graduate student who sets out to write a dissertation on the third Critique now: since Donald Crawford, Francis Coleman, Jens Kulenkampff, Eva Schaper, and I published books on Kant's aesthetics between 1974 and 1979 there has been a continuing flood of articles (this journal receives more submissions on Kant's aesthetics annually than on any other historical topic) and books, a flood that has only accelerated since 2000.2 Confining myself only to monographs and anthologies on Kant's aesthetics or the third Critique as a whole (but not those devoted exclusively to teleology) in English, German, and French on my shelves, and no doubt missing some, at least in German and French, I find twenty‐eight monographs and anthologies published in the period between 1980 and 1999 and another twenty‐seven just since 2000. (Indeed, two more have arrived on my desk since this article was written.)3 Someone setting out to work on the third Critique now has at least as many books from the last decade alone to read as I had in 1971 from the eight preceding decades. The present review will make only a small dent in this pile: I will discuss just five monographs and one introduction to the third Critique, all published in English in 2006 and 2007. A natural question to ask before turning to these volumes is what are the outstanding interpretative issues that have been raised in previous discussions of Kant's aesthetics and might fruitfully allow for further discussion? These issues might be divided into those that concern Kant's aesthetics alone and those that concern the place of his aesthetic theory in the larger project of the third Critique and in Kant's philosophy as a whole. Among the former, the key issue has certainly been how we should understand Kant's key concept of the harmonious play of the cognitive powers of imagination and understanding in our response to and of of since this issue other issues Kant's as the between and between the of and the of and between the and the The of Kant's of the of of also on the of the play of the cognitive as as to the question of how is to be to the more of that in the to the third Among the issues that the of Kant's aesthetic theory there is the question of the between Kant's theory of aesthetic on the one and the theory of as as his theory of on the and the question of how Kant's aesthetic theory and the of the third Critique as a whole are to be to the of Kant's to the theory of of the Critique of on the one and to the philosophy of the the Critique of and the of on the of the monographs in the as as the one work at of the issues just to how the two of the third Critique are to other or to how the third Critique is to the of Kant's I will discuss those and to two that are at Kant's aesthetic theory I on and of the Critique of was and the of the for on Kant's Critique of the of Judgment has not to the of the of as the of and of Kant's of aesthetic and his of that this is because the two that to his of these the of and have been is to Kant's on of these in of the concept of not discuss in any two of the further of that in the third Critique, of the of and the whole of as a than that as a than the of our of and not discuss the on the at is to how the of and of and aesthetic in response to all be in of The two of the are not but should be as concern the of and of the of I should be and should be aesthetic a I will the of my to of Kant's might to to the of Kant's but also the of work to Kant's two on this but only on Kant's theory of the of and of and on of Kant's aesthetics issues that will in the other books to be of will be of to of this is a concept for one ask the between Kant's of this concept to on the one and aesthetic on the other are as as and much on this concept not from what is the of the third Critique, what I might a a the in aesthetic and are to of the of that is for the of the of of as of a for the of the of of natural in and of this for to find of the in the of for of the of in and in aesthetic to as to is and on the one Kant's theory of be to or natural in and and no while on the other in a as a of the of the be as a or as in a of the key of the of are or to a or a concept of that this is or what is present and or to what is not present but or should to be or and that the of and are to be in a the to in the of of in that of the and of in or in make that the in is than to in of are no the the of the of there is a but only to the concept of a of the of natural in have had a for his in the of we our a of and not to but to a but the and in the of aesthetic there is the of or of the aesthetic the of and any of this but Kant's and aesthetics is the of on the of the as and also the of is in two as is in his of in the third Critique but is in his and of the natural of than of the of the is as to his of as that of the and is as of the as is on in the of in the larger of the of the of that from the of to the of as a to the of than the of our of the of a of to the of a of only be the one of the of in Kant's is that the of natural but that our or of the of to of as a whole as a and that to the or of a and that in to of the of our as the only of the of the of all in be to this out to be on the of only of Kant's the third Critique, was not philosophy of for his that the of in to be a for but his our of as the in a larger our to I that the between Kant's and his aesthetics is his that aesthetic in of of any the of also that is a that is to our and that is only as this that has a to to aesthetic of concern of is that a concept is to as a that is and in of to to Kant's of aesthetic and his of what the a of the one that the only for a in the of aesthetic is the that is in to the only that is a aesthetic that is not the but the of this in the as the of that is in a of as a for that the only that is to be a in a of is the of the that the has the only for a for aesthetic is the of the of one in all for in that the of the for in that is also to be a for the of aesthetic no at all of the concept of on the other Kant's of the of of in the published to the last of this in the of of the and a that certainly has as a to as any that the concept of is not and the in a to Kant's of aesthetic is the of the of of a of this to a concept for a the is not to the but to the and the but to the cognitive that are in play in the of as are in and a of the this of as to than that of in the imagination place the of at least to for to certainly that in as we as a concept for a but also that the of the to our of is that we but not make any to a that is not any not that or a is a that aesthetic should to or in is a of the of of the aesthetic that is to the that a in a and how a for response and I find that a is a for aesthetic in the in is a for is to be a that the of to of the at the but also to the of the of will find that this between the of the of aesthetic on the one and the and of this on the other the to be as I now to issues in aesthetic theory on to my but issues that I are of I that my of Kant's of is while is the of aesthetic as to to find in a and that on Kant's of aesthetic is to the and aesthetic is a response to the on my aesthetic are as to of in to a than to the my to of just that have the to a in a of least in our be to aesthetic as to our aesthetic to be a in the the not just a or a of in but of the that of the as the The the of the that make the that is are of or and our in the is our to these of and that are to the we the or of our but not the of our as is to be on my and of I to make to what I as of Kant's of our in a for a of aesthetic and to as that in the of aesthetic we to the of that is a will the of imagination and understanding and of to the on my the play of our cognitive powers is to be Kant's of what our to the but not we to in of to the on my that this of is to only the of that not not be what we to of to the be I that Kant's theory that one might to of one is one should make a of that that is not to but should be or a of one has is of the in this of one will have to to and in to other than the play of the that the has and to than of that I not that the of what might be our on the of aesthetic a of aesthetic I that that the of or a of on our response to or that is to the I not that of into the that will that is certainly to and is as the that is the of and that and that from all the other that be the this is what a from a concept Critique of A a of and that make is also to make is for one or another we might not not and to the of and is the to my we find only because we find only of and and or in because only a play of our cognitive that is a not our to cognitive as a we might find and for the play of our and or find that at all the play of our I as much the of as that find the of a to be as to be or in to one as to make the other of the to make the the that find a to is only in the of that we find the to be and that not in the that we to to the is third is that of to of Kant's of the play of the cognitive the of Kant's aesthetic as any of that aesthetic of to we play the of play in of our from one or of the to the of a to be but not any of the to the of our is of the cognitive to in of the as we our from one to another of as from one as one another in and The play in aesthetic is a play of and between in to a as this to be we the of any and to to the is also a of to have a more of imagination in certainly has a of the imagination as more than just between of in his of the of of that in his theory of the is as to present or the that is at the of is what is to the of the play of the imagination is certainly not to or and of but in the of but in the to the the work that aesthetic Kant's of the play of the imagination be a of a more of than of to and that make the that of the of the is also on in aesthetic as we is on one of the between aesthetic and are two issues the of the that are the or of aesthetic and the of the that is the of aesthetic for the in to a between the of the that are the of in the present of to the and of the whole as but only as had been to of the the or of of aesthetic of aesthetic to of play as in a aesthetic in aesthetic is as to the whole of is of many of the or in the I find this of for two is between the aesthetic and the aesthetic in as the of a play or or the of a the aesthetic is to the only that to that at one in the of the only of but in other as those of or the of is present to the at and will only be the of that will be all is for and allow for the has in doubt there are that the I have just as the of a natural is to the from one but in a as the and to that in the of the aesthetic or to of and not be how we are to the we find in in and in other these that are just as as the of a aesthetic as the of a of the of a but of the the of the and of of these of be to our of the in the of a work that is present at the of and the of the just as much as I find no for to the that only the are other concern is of the of aesthetic to is of a larger between my of Kant's of aesthetic and in this journal in in in of the in the as a that is the of the play of the in to the of of on and we have to from to a that is not the of a of that not from other of might be a of of there is the of is also one I a that has out to be that is to a or between the of aesthetic of to the of in and the of that to of the that is The is the that one has be to the former, in the of of be to that aesthetic is a that is the as the play of our cognitive will of the of play of the of of of aesthetic as this in Kant's of as of the in a is in as a for this the of the other in a or for in the Critique that the that is of the in the play of the cognitive powers of the has a in that of the of the of the and the of the cognitive powers a further the of the because this and I Kant's because that German has only this one for the and of A what a is to the concept or Kant's to that is not a as to but a cognitive a is a that is another the in of that this to will that be another that is the in of that and to a I Kant's to other a is any that we to or in the as to a is any that we to and in the since is a we to of we to in the of a that that at least the no or or the of the or for that the in the not that we or to the of I no to Kant's to more than to that aesthetic has a that is to the of the only to that is a for the of a A and is that is not a of at all we are from the of and are on our to what his of is to a of that are as one has to that have the of a I that what this is that is to is and not a of the of a not have are the only that be in is that have a to this is not to that are but in any be is to that are that have a a since this is all not just aesthetic I not that to Kant's of in of of his of aesthetic as to other of I to of what I have as two and in Kant's aesthetic The of to I have is the that I make between Kant's of the of our cognitive powers that to our in a of I in the that to a play of our cognitive the of the that in a has and that the be the of the I of of in the that one that is the and not a or of I have that this is to from in the to the of for the is will there that a the of will of other has as that the aesthetic of the that to the of that to the of to the of aesthetic in we is our any period of on our to make the our than of the Kant's that aesthetic is on my the of a and aesthetic out of the of understand the aesthetic not as a more as to our of aesthetic and to the of that The I is the of the the of as and in that I certainly to that there is a between what I as two of or on my is on the of in that only a my since the of the is not to and the that to the that is this that has a that and of this is as any as any the of a how be that was just that there be a between the of the that to on the one and the of a the of that and the on that be to in one had to on the that a be is I not only because is the only to out Kant's but also because is the only to that I a or that is that that my in is and that I that my in is not to the play of my cognitive powers but to of these to the aesthetic and the aesthetic of be are not and this I to how make for Kant's the of of to the of the of in a to the that I have but aesthetic as not only but also and as have and in the to be in for the from Kant's of aesthetic I have the of in a of the to a to a that I have to a a of a play of my cognitive to that and also to a out the that should or to to the as I or the on to I that the of Kant's in the of that the from the of the of the one the question to Kant's of of is to is as the is a from of in of this as to the of the in other a to for the of and to this question that the for in that are are also for to a in a that to the play of cognitive powers and to in not to a should or but only a on the other this the that only is that the of of is of as a and that is only as is the of the that is also of as a and a to the of Kant's the of the of is and a and not The of of is to that is to that one has to be be to and only the further that the is a of the is to that in to be to not in I that to find the as I the of of to just this of the of Kant's of aesthetic and the between the of aesthetic and of the in in a that is not a of in the one and the of the of in the out in the to have but only of further of of my on and is a and that should the of Kant's aesthetic theory a of that of the of the in the of I two books that the of the third Critique for Kant's philosophy as a whole but in also to of the of the The of is is Kant's and to that aesthetic the of the of the of the of only be in in the Critique of and of this to the to aesthetics many is that Kant's of aesthetic to the of the Critique of and on this to the of of any between aesthetic and and between those of and Kant's philosophy one concern the between aesthetic and the of of that is Kant's in of the to the Critique of the of of the of aesthetic the one to that aesthetic the of a of that between the of on the one and on the other the of on in a that no for any of the on the other to that the of the play of the imagination and understanding in aesthetic as of the of the of in and of all of that is for but missing from Kant's of the of the of in the and of the I not how have The of are to that as from the of of a of and a and to the of in Kant's of not have that this any but two in to make that the what of and as have all of the of to the on the and no for any the as to that the is the or of that only the of and is not the the that of as and much to the of the of and the of understanding and not for the of a or to on many of reading of these is not I much doubt any of of or in third that the the are the to any to but the a is only as is in to what is in as and is for but also aesthetic of the the in for any I are to a for understanding Kant's of the of the of imagination and understanding in aesthetic response as a that in the and of the of the in the Critique, to a of the of that no for a the of the of and in a concept in the might to for a of that of the for and for a play of the cognitive than only a of that this in of his that a and the of the the imagination as a in all and might to the for a of aesthetic that all is all is from for of aesthetic response to the theory of in the Critique, to be that the Critique to the of the play of cognitive that a is a that any of Kant's aesthetics before a of the is the one just that aesthetic we of the or between the two of a that in other to are able to at the of the because of the a of the aesthetic we of or and our to the no of what the of aesthetic are that from to our a as the of the Critique on we has the of the is to allow in to in the between and I of and Kant's that of a of the of the on the that is in to to our in the other two that of the of understanding and or play or of the that we we to be is a of the of the for any that any at not to that has two of the play of the what I have as the and on the of aesthetic is to place of the of any as the of of the of any but on the of aesthetic is not to the of to the of aesthetic are to in of and but are to a of or that what is just to and that is not all that the that the of a is only the I the of Kant's key concept in aesthetic theory his key in the theory of not to the between the two of play no has the than to the to that the that that the play of the in aesthetic is a of that and the of in a concept in that the of that is at work in all has been a of that is not at work in all at the of in to that the of while of how the the or as a of a of from the that aesthetic to be a than of not not should be of aesthetic as a of a more cognitive of we have a to on or more on the of just because the of the but not the aesthetic than the should this the that aesthetic to is one that not just any but only a might to be that to find a to the on but for that be a for is a at not for his Kant's is that place from the that are of the in the of the Critique of A is for the of Kant's and is to the and that to for our cognitive from any of of the of imagination in the in the Critique, a in the of the we from and before our only as be the of the imagination and our other cognitive are not and there is no to that aesthetic to the of our cognitive powers in to the of aesthetic the for his theory of that Kant's aesthetics is to is not a that have at a on the and of in the Critique that not aesthetic at to the of aesthetic in and a that aesthetic a of that I not be The issue is the in of the to the third Cri
Guyer, P. D. (2009). The Harmony of the Faculties in Recent Books on the Critique of the Power of Judgment. Journal of Aesthetics and Art Criticism. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1540-6245.2009.01349.x
Imported from OpenAlex (CC0) — nothing here is generated.