This article claims that students who refuse actively participate in their own learning are acting unethically. Standards borrowed from Richard L. Johannesen's Ethics in Human Communication 4th ed. are employed as support for this claim. Silence impedes student learning, teacher effectiveness and classmate benefits from learning from silent students' insights, observations, and experiences. Among most frustrating classroom phenomena is that of students who will not or can not actively participate in classroom discussions. Student reticence, withdrawal, or fear of interacting not only deprives that student from sharing what they know, it deprives teacher and classmates from benefiting by what a given student has offer. This article makes claim that student reticence has a vital ethical dimension it and that there is an individual, teacher, classmate, and administrative obligation reduce or eliminate such reticence for benefit of all involved in education arena. Participatory dialogue, according Martin Buber, forecast the future of mankind (Glatzer, 1966). Student silence in class is not exclusively a problem for students who refuse or are unable respond direct questions. The need for students ask questions of clarification, exemplification, classification, validation, and curiosity; be able and willing provide examples that demonstrate that student's understanding and that will aid others in seeing examples not thought of by others; and be able and willing civilly challenge others' ideas and claims are paramount for optimum education transpire in classroom. Everyone in classroom is responsible for pulling their own weight; all need participate -- by discussing and by listening others. Why is an individual's silence deemed undesirable or detrimental? There are multiple responses this question. One answer is that undo student silence typically indicates any of following symptoms: (1) apathy toward topic at hand or learning process itself; (2) a student who is not comprehending, is overwhelmed, or is bored; (3) a student who is self- or other isolated from learning community; and/ or (4) a student who has not learned value of or strategies of engagement or who does not appreciate or believe in that value. Silent students deprive themselves and classmates from benefit of their knowledge, their insights, and their thinking. Much learning stems from idea and perception sharing. Often, others' contributions stimulate more and better thinking and sharing from others; dialogue promotes a learning symbiosis. Except in certain contexts, meaning of any silence is inherently ambiguous and therefore subject misinterpretation and misevaluation (Saville-Troike, 1985). This highlights need for careful and sensitive handling by teachers of student silences in classroom. The reticent student is less likely apply, extend, or transfer what is learned than are non-reticent students. Application, extension, and transference are indirectly, but cogently, related dialog since they require cooperation, risk taking, trust, acceptance, and tolerance with others as does dialog. The reticent student is typically self-absorbed and needs compassionate, but insistent, encouragement and enablement participate. There are several reasons why students are reticent actively and equally participate in class discussion; these include: (1) low self esteem -- students who think of themselves as unworthy or unable tend remain silent out of shame; (2) fear of being ridiculed should they inappropriately or inaccurately respond -- unfortunately, such fears can manifest themselves in self-fulfilling prophesies where a student knowingly answers or responds inappropriately thus validating their fears; (3) fear of success -- this occurs when a student interacts successfully; self-attributes their success luck or accident; and then is intrepid about others expecting student continue interact with similar or superior success in future, coupled with doubts such future success can be produced; (4) cultural differences -- various cultures forbid or strongly discourage individuals from speaking up in classroom settings; sometimes for reasons of deference out of respect for teachers' opinions, elder students' or higher status students' contributions, and/or gender/race/ethnicity related factors; (5) to avoid conflict -- inexperienced, shy, or less competent communicators rely upon silence in avoiding conflict scenarios. …
Petress, K. (2001). The Ethics of Student Classroom Silence. Journal of instructional psychology.
Imported from OpenAlex (CC0) — nothing here is generated.