No open-access location is known for this record yet.
No open-access location is known for this record yet.
W A T ith the possible exception of intonation contour and its obvious connection with generic illocutionary force, the contribution of the phonological features of sentences to their overall significance has not received much attention from philosophers of language. One of the few philosophers to recognize the importance of phonological considerations in philosophical linguistics is Fred Dretske, whose pioneering studies [5] and [6] not only provide a rich source of provocative data concerning the phenomenon of contrastive stress but also attempt to weave these data into semantic theory in the large. The resulting theory of the semantic role of contrastive stress is then alleged to have novel and far-reaching consequences for epistemology and metaphysics. Since contrastive stress seems to provide a paradigm case of phonological features affecting our interpretation of utterances, it behooves us to understand its workings aright. Accordingly, my aim in this essay is twofold: first, to criticize Dretske's account of his data and its alleged philosophical fallout; second, and more importantly, to discern the source of Dretske's error and to erect a correct theory of the effect of contrastive stress on our interpretation of utterances. Section I offers an overview of the salient features of Dretske's theory of contrastive stress. Section II points out some unpleasant consequences of adopting such a view. Section III locates Dretske's error at the methodological level and introduces a crucial consideration about the ranking of his data. In light of this ranking, it is argued that contrastive stress can play three importantly different roles in our interpretation of utterances: a syntactic role, detailed in Section IV; a semantic-pragmatic role, detailed in Sections V-VI; and a purely pragmatic role, detailed in Sections VII-VIII.
Loading…
Stored only when both papers are in the corpus — 27 citations exist upstream.
Imported from OpenAlex (CC0) — nothing here is generated.