No open-access location is known for this record yet.
No open-access location is known for this record yet.
Like many of the other episodes in the latter half of Ulysses, where Joyce's stylistic experiments become particularly intrusive and extravagant, the Ithaca chapter has been a source of controversy ever since the public got its first look at Joyce's usylessly unreadable Blue Book of Eccles' in 1922. Despite the author's stated preference for this ugly duckling chapter,2 many critics have found the style tedious, effective only through its contrast with the exuberance of Bloom's monologue in Penelope. Even those who have recognized the episode's graceful, swanlike properties have often found themselves unable to accept the complex response required by a passage like the so-called of Molly's (731)3 which has become a familiar crux in studies of Ulysses. The original assumption, that the list is to be taken at face value as a literal catalogue of those who have entered Molly's bed, reigned virtually unchallenged through almost four decades of Ulysses criticism; thus Frank Budgen, one of the most sensible of Joyce's critics, could summarize the passage in question by saying, Bloom considers the whole series of Marion's lovers and especially the latest addition thereto and recent occupant of his bed, Blazes Boylan.4 In 1959 Richard Ellmann spoke out loud and bold on the subject, dismissing virtually all the lovers and stating that had only two extramarital lovers, Bartell D'Arcy and Boylan.5 Three years later Robert M. Adams temporarily reduced the list still further by scoffing at the evidence against D'Arcy, but proceeded to vitiate his own argument by assuming that Molly must have had more lovers than Joyce explicitly tells us (one); Adams concluded rather weakly that some of these men [on the list] slept with and others didn't, and one major point of the passage is that it doesn't make much difference. 6 Over the past two decades other critics have poked more holes in the catalogue (although there is still the occasional glib reference to Molly's
Loading…
Imported from OpenAlex (CC0) — nothing here is generated.