No open-access location is known for this record yet.
No open-access location is known for this record yet.
The result of a 1993 conference on Yucatecan history and culture, this edited volume brings together a well-known group of yucatecólogos to offer new interpretations about older regional topics. That it took 17 years to go from conference to book is unfortunate, although Gilbert Joseph’s epilogue (“Some Final Thoughts on Regional History and the Encounter with Modernity at Mexico’s Periphery”) is new and weaves in some, but not all, of the more recent works on Yucatecan history and how they would apply to the themes presented here. In fact, scholars of Yucatán should find Joseph’s essay to be one of the more useful in the book, especially from a historiographical perspective. All in all, the volume offers an update to older, but still pertinent, collections as those of Edward Moseley and Edward Terry, Yucatán: A Word Apart (1980); Gilbert Joseph, Rediscovering the Past at Mexico’s Periphery (1986); and Jeffery Brannon and Gilbert Joseph, Land, Labor, and Capital in Modern Yucatán (1991). Like those works, this one is published by the University of Alabama Press, adding to its reputation as the English-language leader in Yucatecan studies. This new book should be used in tandem with these older studies, especially to view Yucatecan history as both distinctively regional (and in some ways peripheral), but also integrated into the larger Mexican whole. In contrast, most of the contributors in Peripheral Visions seek to answer newer questions about the effects of modernization on Yucatecan life and culture, especially as Joseph explains it, “the nexus of religious culture and politics” and how that “affords a deeper understanding of Yucatan’s modernizing process and its limits.”After an introductory essay by Helen Delpar and Ben W. Fallaw that nicely sets up the major themes, the editors divide the book into two parts. The first includes seven essays on “Society and Politics,” and part 2 includes four on “Religion.” Like any edited volume, some of the contributions seem more useful than others, but they all work together to discuss modernity and its effects on aspects of Yucatecan society. Delpar describes how that was reflected (nay, advertised) abroad in chapter 2, regarding Yucatecan boosters’ attempts to market both the state’s archeological and natural resources. Some struggles with modernity were more successful than others, for example the progress in labor (as attested to in Paul K. Eiss’s excellent chapter 3 on labor politics in Yucatán from 1915 to 1918), but less so for the long-range success of women’s reforms or land reforms. Stephanie J. Smith, in chapter 4, wants readers to see that progress was made for women’s rights but fails to show how any revolutionary reforms crossed class lines or how they benefitted Maya Indian women or campesinas in rural Yucatán. Likewise, Fallaw in chapter 5 illustrates how many of the well-intentioned reforms advocated by President Lázaro Cárdenas did not enjoy long-lasting success. Included here is discussion of the rapid decline in the henequen industry, but Fallaw neglects some newer insights on the significant impact of changes in harvesting technology that ended the demand for Yucatecan fiber — analysis that could have illustrated how expanded modernization abroad led to decreased modernization in Yucatán. On the other hand, some modernization attempts came from without, such as the Lebanese immigrant merchants whom Eric N. Baklanoff discusses in chapter 6, although more proof of the significance of this small population would be welcome. Stylistically, it is unfortunate that the editors allowed Baklanoff to use parenthetical notation instead of footnotes as used in every other chapter.Arguably the most important contribution to part 1 is chapter 7 on the decline of Yucatán’s henequen industry by historical sociologist Othón Baños. Employing both sound research and convincing analysis, Baños minces no words to show how more recent economic trends associated with NAFTA and privatization enacted with the revision of Article 17 of the Mexican constitution during the Carlos Salinas sexenio (1988 – 94) dealt significant blows to Yucatán’s final attempts in the henequen industry. Writes Baños, the actions were “taken without considering the prevalent social and historical conditions that would have easily predicted that the ejidatarios were unprepared for individual management of private property” (p. 146). This chapter is a welcome addition to fill in the historiographical lacunae in post-1970s Yucatecan history and political economy.Part 2 on religion adds important dimensions to regional cultural history. But while Lynda Morrison’s chapter 7 is too narrowly focused on the life of one particular priest, Terry Rugeley’s chapter 8 provides rich analysis over a broad sweep of time about the important role religion played in rural rebellions. This section’s final two essays deal with the resurgence of the church during the Porfiriato (Hernán Menéndez Rodríguez with Ben W. Fallaw) and church-state relations in Yucatán during and after the Mexican Revolution (Fallaw).Combined, these various essays in Peripheral Visions provide important new insights into the cultural understanding of modern Yucatán. It is not a collection that could be used in too many survey history courses on Mexico or Latin America, but it is one that all students of Yucatecan history should own and read.
Loading…
Imported from OpenAlex (CC0) — nothing here is generated.