No open-access location is known for this record yet.
No open-access location is known for this record yet.
DIFFERENT HISTORICITIES In his study of various Polynesian traditions, Marshall Sahlins has observed that what constitutes a significant account of past is very differently formulated in narrative systems of different island groups.(1) Each tradition cultivates a distinctive pattern of expectation and plausibility in its selection and reconstruction of historical events. These events are assimilated to underlying recurrent of tradition of narration.(2) Such structures serve to organize random multiplicity of events into meaningful patterns of eventuality. The perceived or potential trueness of a story, its authority as an accurate representation of historical reality, depends in large part upon its reproduction of familiar sequences to which participants in tradition have long since been acculturated. Different cultures, different historicities, Sahlins concludes.(3) Carol Clover summarizes a similar view of family sagas, narrative traditions of early Icelandic Commonwealth elaborated centuries later in written form: the original stories sprang from historical reality but ... once set in oral motion, they were slowly but surely rationalized, localized, contemporized, and above all `traditionalized' (repatterned according to narrative `laws' of that society).(4) Joseph Harris has called most fundamental of these narrative laws the plot of history.(5) This plot supplies an implicit temporal paradigm which disciplines and informs all subsequent attempts at narration in that tradition. Poets and storytellers imitate old plots as much or more than any actual sequence of events they may observe because those plots encode way things are understood generally and characteristically to transpire. For those inside cultural world of tradition, plot structure reinforces their understanding of way events unfold through time. What John Foley says of other formal features of oral tradition--verbal formulae and themes--applies with even greater force to traditional plots: they are not only compositional. are also cognitive. They not only contain information; they refer in an institutionalized way to other information and determine perception and reception of whole.(6) New narratives recreate world of tradition and, by participating in that larger system of historical signification, come to be taken seriously themselves as true stories. Narratives which satisfy traditional expectations thus enjoy a special force in confidence of their auditors, an a priori validity and significance. As Richard J. Parmentier, another Polynesian ethnographer, writes: While multiple descriptions of `same' event constitute proof for some historians that oral narratives are unreliable, they also provide a perfect opportunity to uncover cultural principles behind narrative genres. That is, oral traditions express an implicit theory--or theories--of historical process which should not be dismissed as mere ideological bias or contextual skewing.(7) These theories of history embodied in traditional plots are crucial cultural artifacts, highly significant of that culture's peculiar construction of way world works through time. In fact, cultural theories of temporal process only clearly reveal themselves as artificial, rather than natural, when they come into conflict with alternative or competing traditions of eventuality. A culture can materialize only in contradistinction to another culture, observes James A. Boon: before any culture be experienced as a culture displacement from it must be possible; ... there is no place outside it to be except in other cultures or in their fragments and potentialities (his emphasis).(8) The main point to be taken in application of these principles to an interpretation of Old English poetry is that traditional plot structures remain remarkably active and influential, even when challenged by traditions of historical process which enjoy superior cultural prestige. …
Loading…
Stored only when both papers are in the corpus — 23 citations exist upstream.
Imported from OpenAlex (CC0) — nothing here is generated.