It is difficult to think of anyone better suited to write Voces contra la mediocridad: La vanguardia teatral de los Provincetown Players, 1915–1922 than Dr. Noelia Hernando-Real. An internationally recognized scholar, Hernando-Real is the author of publications including Performing Gender Violence: Plays by Contemporary American Women Dramatists (co-edited with Barbara Ozieblo) and Self and Space in the Theater of Susan Glaspell, alongside a number of book chapters and articles, most of them concerned with gender and/or early twentieth-century American drama.1 She has published extensively on American women playwrights, Susan Glaspell most notably. Indeed, she currently serves as president of the Susan Glaspell International Society. The first Spanish-language approach to the history of the Provincetown Players has thus been entrusted to capable hands.The history of Spanish-language scholarship on American drama is not long. It started in the 1980s, with pioneering efforts by Rodríguez Celada, Pardo Gutiérrez, and Gómez García.2 Over the years, readers in Spain with limited access to English-language studies have seen the number of monographs increase, some offering approaches to specific playwrights (Tennessee Williams, Arthur Miller, Maxwell Anderson, Marsha Norman, Terrence McNally, Sophie Treadwell, Sam Shepard), some dealing with other aspects of drama, and at least one general overview.3 It also seems that over the years studies have become growingly specific. Some gaps will, however, be referred to later, and I will build from there to offer what is my only (largely minor) objection to the volume under review.Such body of work as has come out in Spain has mostly focused on contemporary drama. An exception was Pardo Gutiérrez's aforementioned 1984 contribution, where she covered early American drama up to O'Neill. But she referred to the Provincetown Players only in passing. Hernando-Real provides, then, a new chapter in this history of Spanish-language approaches to American drama, picking up where Gutiérrez left off several decades ago. And she does so in a collection responsible for much of the aforementioned work, the Biblioteca Javier Coy d'Estudis Nord-Americans, published by the University of Valencia, for which the tireless and dauntless Dr. Carme Manuel is responsible. Without her strenuous and dedicated work for decades, the bulk of American studies scholarship in Spain (both written in English and Spanish) would be a half of what it now is.Voces contra la mediocridad is an excellent chance to become acquainted with the aesthetics and history of such an iconic and productive group (almost 100 plays, by 47 American playwrights) as the Provincetown Players, or the Players, as they are commonly known. Hernando-Real provides a season-by-season account of their productions; discusses general currents within the development of the group (financial, aesthetic, theatrical); and does not shy away from considering more personal matters where she feels they may be useful to better understand what happened and why.4 By the end of the first part, the reader has obtained a thorough understanding of how the group evolved over the years, as well as the factors leading to its disbanding. In the second part, Hernando-Real provides her own translation of a selection of plays performed by the group at various times, written in different styles and belonging to a multitude of genres. Everything explained in the first section is thus submitted to the reader for a closer, hands-on inspection.As the first Spanish publication exclusively devoted to the Provincetown Players, there is little fault to find with Hernando-Real's rigorous, exhaustive, well-argued, well-documented, highly readable monograph. The plays translated constitute a representative selection, ranging from distinctly second-rate work like George Cram Cook's Change Your Style and the pompous and platitudinous Louise Bryant's The Game to surprisingly good fare like James Oppenheim's Night, and increasingly popular plays like Susan Glaspell's The Verge (far superior, in my view, to Inheritors, also included in the anthology) and Edna St. Vincent Millay's Aria da Capo. None of them had been translated into Spanish before, so once again the usefulness of the volume cannot be overstated. Maybe the texts should be honed down before production, as they occasionally sound slightly odd in Spanish. But I verily suspect that Hernando-Real, as a scholar and not a theater director, has rightly perceived her job as to offer translations that are more accurate and faithful to the originals than necessarily “say-able.” Concerning quotations from English, Hernando-Real has opted for translating them and gives such translations between quotes. A better idea would have been, I reckon, to give both versions, and only the English one between quotes.Were this not a journal devoted to Eugene O'Neill, my review could have concluded with the foregoing paragraph. But I need to briefly consider how the book contributes to a better understanding of the playwright. Precisely one of the gaps to which I alluded before was the scarcity of secondary material on him, excepting the occasional production review, or some issue in specialized journals, usually not easy to locate. No Spanish-language monograph on O'Neill has ever been published in Spain, an inconceivable omission, particularly poignant given the work undertaken on lesser-known (and less often produced) dramatists. Concerning his plays, Argentinian translations, generally quite inadequate, circulated extensively in Spain in the 1950s and 1960s, penned by León Mirlas, who held the rights to O'Neill's translations into Spanish. Mirlas became one of the most hated persons among the Spanish theatrical community of the period, given how hard his texts were to work with or read. This does not sit well with Hernando-Real's claim that O'Neill “ha sido magistralmente traducido al español, como en el caso de las traducciones de Ana Antón-Pacheco y de León Mirlas [has been masterfully translated into Spanish, by the likes of Ana Antón Pacheco and León Mirlas]” (16).Some recent work deserves mention, although it is not sufficient to substantiate Hernando-Real's claim. A 2001 annotated edition and translation of More Stately Mansions by Álvaro del Amo came out.5 Three more plays have been graced with substantial Spanish editions, prepared by our national O'Neill expert, Ana Antón-Pacheco: one volume was devoted to Long Day's Journey Into Night in 1986, and another, pairing Hughie and The Iceman Cometh, was published in 2001.6 But, one is safe to conclude, O'Neill's work has been underrepresented in Spain, both as to scholarly approaches and even more so when it comes to his plays. That such a towering figure of American (and worldwide) drama in the twentieth century has suffered from such neglect is a matter for wonder as well as puzzlement.Hernando-Real's new contribution was an excellent chance to amend, at least to a certain extent, such neglect. Naturally, in the first section of the book, all of the plays that O'Neill produced for the Players are duly addressed. But none of them makes its way into the second part. Hernando-Real surely believed his work was sufficiently known among Spanish readers. And he is indeed well known in Spain, but there is such a searing scarcity of secondary and primary material about him that one is to conclude that such fame may be without a very solid foundation (at least for all those who cannot read English).Such complaint as I have formulated above is intended as a clarion call to other Spanish scholars on the need to engage with O'Neill much more steadfastly than heretofore, not as a reflection on the significance of Hernando-Real's book. Forgetting O'Neill for the time being, her monumental work will undoubtedly remain the standard Spanish-language reference guide to the work of the Players for generations to come, offering on the side an insightful glimpse into the makings of modern drama, which stems in great part from groups such as the Players. They sometimes were avant-garde, sometimes traditional, forward-looking, yet also self-absorbed, always trying to balance the idealism of young theater practitioners with what Arthur Miller once encapsulated in his famous dictum that theater is merely, in the last stance, the “art of the possible” (312).7
Romero, R. E. (2018). Voces Contra la Mediocridad: La Vanguardia Teatral de los Provincetown Players, 1915–1922. The Eugene O Neill Review. https://doi.org/10.5325/eugeoneirevi.39.1.0174
Imported from OpenAlex (CC0) — nothing here is generated.