No open-access location is known for this record yet.
No open-access location is known for this record yet.
This volume is the first to appear of the planned five-volume Oxford History of Classical Reception in English Literature (OHCREL). It covers the period 1660–1790; still to come are volumes 1 (800–1558), 2 (1558–1660), 4 (1790–1880), and 5 (after 1880). The present volume is edited by the series editors, David Hopkins and Charles Martindale, both of whom are professors emeriti at Bristol University and world-renowned scholars in the literature of the period and in classical reception. Thus, this collection clearly functions as the series' flagship volume.Hopkins and Martindale are known for their shared commitment to a hermeneutic/aesthetic approach to reception. Three main characteristics distinguish their approach from others within the field of classical reception and from the broader community of reception scholars; all three are stated as programmatic for the OHCREL project in the preface and the introduction to the present volume.First, Hopkins and Martindale focus on what they call, unapologetically (even defiantly), “literary texts of high quality” by “great writers,” with visual texts, including comics, films, and theatrical performances, excluded from the category of the literary. Second, they understand writers as readers, and literary texts as creative/critical readings of the ancient texts to which they respond. Third, they understand literary history in terms of a tradition in T. S. Eliot's sense: not passively inherited but acquired by great labor and actively shaped and reshaped by successive generations of writers. This tradition, they believe, forms a more important context for literary criticism and interpretation than social, political, or book history does; Martindale argues this point cogently at the start of his own contribution to this volume, “Milton's Classicism.” Overall, in their broader work and in this volume, Hopkins and Martindale theorize reception as a dialogue between two distinct historical periods.This dialogic and text-based understanding of reception—and, concomitantly, of literary history—leaves its mark both on the organization of this volume and on its contents. In terms of the organization, although all the chapters focus on the use made of classical works by literary writers in the period 1660–1790, all but two chapters are positioned on one side or another of the dialogue. (The two exceptions are discussed in more detail below.) Thus some chapters focus on ancient authors, works, or genres, tracing their presence in works of the period, while others focus on seventeenth- and eighteenth-century authors and literary modes and their negotiations with the classics. Consequently, there are three chapters on named authors writing in the period 1660–1790 (“Milton's Classicism,” “Dryden's Classicism,” and “Samuel Johnson's Classicism”), and six on the “afterlife” of ancient authors in the period (“Latin Epic: Virgil, Lucan and Others,” “Homer,” “Ovid,” “Horatianism,” “The Classical Critics,” and “The Ancient Historians in Britain”). Similarly, there are four chapters on specific literary modes of the period (“Travesty and Mock-Heroic,” “The Classics and Eighteenth-Century Theatre,” “The Classics and the English Novel,” and “Discursive and Philosophical Prose”) and six chapters on the impact of ancient literary genres on literature of the period (“Roman Satire and Epigram,” “Pastoral and Georgic,” “Didactic and Scientific Poetry,” “The Epistolary Tradition,” “The Fabular Tradition,” and “Lyric and Elegy”). Inevitably, there is a fair amount of overlap in content: Dryden's relationship with Horace, for example, is discussed at some length in four separate chapters.In terms of the content, the individual chapters are successful in direct proportion to their ability to account for the factors that make dialogue between the two periods possible in the first place. In many of the chapters, reception is understood as something that takes place in the mind of a poet. This interior “mindscape” is a transhistorical space, often separate from or even resistant to the poet's social or historical context: in the chapter on Johnson's classicism, Freya Johnson defines “classical quotation”' as “a community of mind” (634). It is the imaginative, affective, intellectual, or aesthetic space of this community of mind that many of the chapters explore. At best (as in Tom Mason's chapter on Dryden), this approach produces convincing accounts of the affective and experiential dimensions of individuals' engagements with the classics; at worst, it leads to readings of texts as simply vehicles for the “visions” or “messages” of great minds. The focus on a transhistorical community of mind also means that the historical dimension of the project is sometimes undertheorized, and the historical (as opposed to critical) arguments and analyses are not always sufficiently sharp. Several chapters end up as little more than evaluative lists of seventeenth- and eighteenth-century literary works, though even these often contain excellent close readings of individual works.The more successful chapters tend to introduce a mediating term into their account of the “dialogue” between ancient and modern writers, accounting for the literary and historical technologies that make this dialogue possible and thus sharpening these chapters' historical and critical judgments. The best chapters in the collection are those that focus on genre, notably Juan Christian Pellicer's “Pastoral and Georgic,” Fred Parker's “Travesty and Mock-Heroic,” Philip Smallwood's “The Classical Critics,” Henry Power's “The Classics and the English Novel,” and Adam Potkay's “Discursive and Philosophical Prose.” The outstanding essay is Jayne Lewis's “The Fabular Tradition,” which (not coincidentally) is also the most closely aligned with the broader concerns of reception study that extend beyond classical reception scholarship. Lewis's dazzling analyses draw on media history, the materiality of the book, seventeenth- and eighteenth-century literary and anthropological theory, and contemporary ideologies of reading, nature, and legitimacy.In addition to the chapters discussed already, the volume contains two more general chapters by Penelope Wilson: “The Place of Classics in Education and Publishing” and “Women Writers and the Classics.” These are oddly chosen. The educational/publishing background is useful, but more general background information would also have been beneficial. The preface expresses the hope that the volume will appeal to “a wide range of readers from a variety of disciplines and backgrounds, within and outwith the university” (ix), but in practice the collection requires a very high degree of familiarity with the general, social, political, and literary history of the period. Exactly what the reader is assumed to know varies from chapter to chapter, however: for example, a work is described in passing as “Scriblerian” several chapters before a patient explication of the Scriblerus Club's origins and membership is given. More consistency on such matters would help future volumes in the series to speak to a wider range of readers. In the present volume, an excellent annotated bibliography by Victoria Moul will help interested readers fill in gaps in their knowledge.The chapter “Women Writers and the Classics” is interesting in itself, but it is unclear why this group of writers is the only one conceived as a group and given its own chapter. The picture of a separate women's tradition implied by the chapter sits oddly with the way in which different literary schools and positions are mapped elsewhere in the volume, where female authors appear alongside some male writers and in opposition to others. Giving women writers a chapter of their own has also apparently been taken by some contributors as permission to disregard women entirely; for example, the discussion of Pindar and Sappho in David Fairer's chapter on “Lyric and Elegy” makes a number of general statements that, when cross-referenced with Wilson's chapter, turn out to be true only for male writers. Sexuality, particularly homo- or bisexuality (which will surely become an important dimension of the history of classical reception in volumes 4 and 5), is a neglected topic here: what appears to be a thoroughgoing heterosexualization of antiquity in this period passes without comment.Some of the most interesting themes and arguments of the collection emerge across chapters, providing a complex or inconsistent story of the period from a variety of perspectives. A reflective afterword, or a section of the introduction highlighting specific themes and debates covered across chapters and fleshing out the theoretical and historical background to the collection more fully, might have made the conversation between individual chapters more fruitful and would be very welcome in future volumes of the series.Despite these reservations and suggestions, there is no doubt that OHCREL is a landmark series that will be invaluable for scholars of classical reception in English literature. The task it takes on is rightly described in the introduction as both impossible and inevitable. This flagship volume tackles that task creditably, covering its period in both breadth and detail, and setting an agenda for future research.
Loading…
Imported from OpenAlex (CC0) — nothing here is generated.