Dispelling the Fantasy of Innocence: Complicity and the Cultivation of Transgression in Settler Colonial Contexts

Abstract

Abstract This article critically engages with the Canadian framing of settler colonial/decolonial politics in terms of guilt and innocence. I argue that centring innocence, even as something to be snatched away from settlers, as with the theorization of settler moves to innocence, can corrupt the practice of moral responsibility. Furthermore, I argue that the desire for and expectation of innocence, in the face of structural injustices such as settler colonialism, are illusionary and that complicity is widespread. In contrast, I follow Iris Marion Young's focus on political responsibility, but I argue that public collective actions need not be as centred as she suggests. Given the nature of settler colonialism and of coloniality, I argue for the acknowledgment of the political significance of daily individual acts and for the cultivation of dispositions that disrupt unjust structures, such as a disposition to transgress.

Cite this work

Stored copy: cc-by-nc · source https://www.cambridge.org/core/services/aop-cambridge-core/content/view/7C5530840082EE962BCE53394E321EE2/S0008423923000690a.pdf/div-class-title-dispelling-the-fantasy-of-innocence-complicity-and-the-cultivation-of-transgression-in-settler-colonial-contexts-div.pdf. Open access only — a takedown request can remove the copy without touching this record.

Stored only when both papers are in the corpus — 17 citations exist upstream.

Papers that cite the same references — the relational fallback while embeddings are still backfilling.