No open-access location is known for this record yet.
No open-access location is known for this record yet.
Bacevic, Jana (2014). From Class to Identity / The Politics of Education Reforms in Former Yugoslavia. Budapest - New York: CEU press, 235 pp. ISBN 978-615-5225-72-7.Many questions about the reasons for the incredibly violent collapse of the Socialist Federal Republic of Yugoslavia remain unanswered, and probably the 'deepest' of them will never be sufficiently answered. However, thanks not only to the passage of time but also due to slowly accumulating research in different venues of the social sciences and humanities, growing numbers of increasingly convincing interpretations of the historic events and more reliable theories of the social, ethnic, cultural and, above all, political backgrounds are making progress in providing answers. It would be pretentious to say that Yugoslavia serves as an ultimate historical lesson for the future, and it would be overly optimistic to expect that anyone learned their 'lesson', but it is clear now that the Yugoslav example has informed theoretical thinking, and influenced a formation of conceptual constructions concerning topics such as social conflicts, political actors, ideologies and so on. Jana Bacevic's book inscribes itself into this conceptual space with one of the most consistent and clarifying interdisciplinary insights into the structures, processes and twisted logics of the Yugoslav episode in recent European history. The fact that the book is focused on and by education contributes much to the precision of hypotheses and assumptions in the book. At the same time, such a perspective proves to be especially rewarding as it enables the author to dispense with the abundance of cliches, simplifications and other more or less ideologically fashioned 'explanations' of the deplorable end of what once seemed as a promising large-scale political project. Jana Bacevic also clearly demonstrates that taking a view on a society through its central institutional instrument of reproduction is precisely that point of departure, which triggers an eruption of a number of crucial questions on how we understand and interpret a society and especially its conflicts. One such crucial problem is formulated at the beginning of the book: 'The fact that a country with high levels of education managed to disintegrate in a violent conflict strongly challenges the assumption about the preventive nature of education in terms of managing social cleavages' (p. 6). The author later dispels a whole signifying chain of established explanations and accounts of the Yugoslav tragedy, from references to the 'ancient ethnic hatreds' to a number of emphases on 'cultural differences' as presumable reasons for the conflict. However, the book is not merely about dispelling wrong assumptions, but is a nuanced study of the policies and trends in Yugoslav education before and after the war.The Introduction is the first chapter of this admirable study. It is followed by four chapters, which are organised around conceptual core notions as well as around some important historical and institutional issues in the processes. Of course, the Introduction appropriately explains the structure of the book, giving an overview of the research methods and main topics of the book, but it also puts forward many ingenious hypotheses and assumptions. Hence, an interested reader receives a strong incentive to read the entire book through to the end. As I suggested in the first paragraph of my review, Bacevic's postulations in the first chapter build on the Yugoslav experience in order to reformulate a good part of the entire field of education studies. She shows very convincingly that some widely accepted assumptions of a role of education simply do not work, whole simultaneously demonstrating that there is more complex interaction between education, policies and politics, which through political subjectivities and group identities enter social processes. On the bases of such insights, Bacevic makes no secret of her conclusive assertion that the Yugoslav case transcends its particular significance, and it instigates somewhat renewed theories on the role of education policies in different contexts. …
Loading…
Imported from OpenAlex (CC0) — nothing here is generated.