An assessment of syntactic capabilities

Abstract

Editor's introduction In this chapter Berent discusses the performance of adult deaf learners of English on different syntactic structures using the interlanguage perspective that is currently in favor among second language acquisition researchers. With Chomsky's government-binding theory as a framework, Berent discovers a strong general preference for an explicit expression of the canonical NVN (SVO) word order of English finite clauses, which has also been reported in other studies. Possibly suffering from the limitations of a restricted working memory, deaf children, Berent suggests, are thus limited in their ability to extend core grammar to peripheral forms that are marked for various syntactic features. In the second part of the chapter, Berent reports on an attempt to teach certain syntactic structures to a group of students who had failed to show gains in English ability despite continued regular instruction. He found that the ceiling effect persisted among this group and suggests that the difference between deaf students that typically make slow gains and those that reach a ceiling may be related to the degree and nature of the processing limitations that they experience as a result of their hearing loss. The implications of this phenomenon for educators of the deaf are profound. It may be that the goal of teaching a nativelike fluency in English to deaf individuals is, with very few exceptions, an unrealistic one, and that research, as Berent implies, should focus on determining exactly which areas of English grammar are and are not amenable to deaf learners, a task that would certainly be anathema to most ESL teachers .

Cite this work

No public copy is stored for this record, so only the metadata is cited.

Stored only when both papers are in the corpus — 41 citations exist upstream.