Embodying Music

Abstract

Introduction[1] This essay describes a hypothesis of how music becomes internalized into the bodies and minds of listeners.The hypothesis underlies a larger theory of musical meaning, concerning affect, metaphoric reasoning, gender, and other areas of inquiry related to bodily experience, but the implications for these larger areas of meaning must wait until the details of the hypothesis have been made plain.Accordingly, this essay focuses on these details and is only suggestive of some of the implications.[2] The attention to embodiment situates this essay amid other writings, within and beyond music, that are concerned with the role of the body in the construction of meaning.Within music this includes work by Suzanne Cusick on gender (Cusick 1994), Naomi Cumming on subjectivity (Cumming 1997, 2000), and several scholars who have applied ideas from cognitive philosopher Mark Johnson (1987) on metaphor (Saslaw 1996, 1997-98; Zbikowski 1997, 1997-98, 1998; Brower 1997-98; Larson 1997-98).These and other scholars are exploring a lacuna left by the largely disembodied objectivity of our discipline (at least as practiced in the USA), which helps perpetuate, as Cusick puts it, the "mind-body problem."(1) The mimetic hypothesis addresses the matter of embodiment by showing how musical imagery-recalling, planning, or otherwise thinking about music-is partly motor imagery.Motor imagery is imagery related to the exertions and movements of our skeletal-motor system, and in the case of music this involves the various exertions enacted in musical performance.The mimetic hypothesis details how this might play out and suggests how it might underlie conceptualization and meaning.(2) [3] The initial premise of the hypothesis is that part of how we comprehend music is by way of a kind of physical empathy that involves imagining making the sounds we are listening to.This is a special case of the general human proclivity to understand one another via imitation, which we can refer to as mimetic cognition or mimetic comprehension, where "mimetic" is used in the manner specified below; hence, the "mimetic hypothesis."[4] The role of imitation in human cognition has received a good deal of interest recently, and, as demonstrated by the references below, this has now begun to make its way into the field of music theory.For this vein of inquiry to produce good Volume 17, Number 2,

Cite this work

No public copy is stored for this record, so only the metadata is cited.

Stored only when both papers are in the corpus — 144 citations exist upstream.

Papers that cite the same references — the relational fallback while embeddings are still backfilling.